Originally posted by RJHinds
You said. "Whether or not we know the actual mechanism yet is another matter but [b]I'd be willing to bet that "God done it" isn't even close."
Have you now changed your mind?[/b]
Oh go on then, one more. I haven't changed my mind. Although I don't generally gamble, I am not averse to betting on a near certainty. I am as certain as I can be that the mechanism by which a bumblebee flies is not "God done it". Bumblebees can and do fly, observation confirms that. The reason generally quoted for the impossibility of this is calculations showing that the energy rquired is too great. However, experiment reveals that viscosity at the scale of an insect's wing enables greater amounts of air to be moved for less energy expenditure. There, bumblebees can fly and no biologist or fluid dynamicist has blamed god.
Now, this is not suggesting god does not exist or that he has no hand in a bumblebee's flight It seems that scientists are not in the habit of using god as the reason for things. This might be because they don't believe, or because they haven't seen any evidence of divine intervention or even because they think their discovery might be met with howls of derision. Even if the scientist concerned is a fervent believer he is very unlikely to get anything published in a peer reviewed journal that cites god as the reason why bumblebees can fly. Apart from anything else, science is already happy with the fact that bumblebees fly.The data suggests the bet is a near certainty.
It seems to me that constantly trying to insert god into the gaps in our knowledge to prove a point is counterproductive. If we do not know something today that does not mean we will not know tomorrow or next week or a hundred years from now. Current ignorance is no reason to wheel out god as a filling for the gaps in our knowledge. Doesn't your god deserve better than that?
Apart from anything else, if we require god to be constantly fiddling about with his creation, holding bumblebees aloft for example, we are saying that his creation is not really up to scratch. Tell me, when god rested on the seventh day did all the bumblebees plummet to earth? Did the planets suddenly fall out of their orbits? I think you should be able to trust a truly perfect god to make something that works without constant tinkering from the maker.