18 Jan '12 08:03>
I have noticed that some theists seem to think that life has some magical property that can only come from God. There have been a number of comments suggesting that 'life from non-life' is not only impossible but somehow self evidently ludicrous.
I think such thinking has some major flaws, not least of which is a lack of understanding of grey definitions and the dangers of making absolute claims about things that are loosely defined.
So, to demonstrate what I am talking about here, can someone who believes that life can never come from non-life, tell me:
1. How do you define life?
2. Can virus' come from non-life?
3. Can computer virus' come from non-life?
4. Can prions come from non-life?
5. Can self replicating molecules such as RNA come from non-life?
6. If a cell is dismantled is it still 'life'?
6. If man put together parts of a cell that had been dismantled and it 'lives', has he made life from non-life? If not, why not?
7. Is a multicellular organism 'life' as a whole, or only the individual cells. Is a bit of your skin that you scrape off, but still has living human cells 'life'? At what point can it be declared 'dead' or 'non-life'?
I think such thinking has some major flaws, not least of which is a lack of understanding of grey definitions and the dangers of making absolute claims about things that are loosely defined.
So, to demonstrate what I am talking about here, can someone who believes that life can never come from non-life, tell me:
1. How do you define life?
2. Can virus' come from non-life?
3. Can computer virus' come from non-life?
4. Can prions come from non-life?
5. Can self replicating molecules such as RNA come from non-life?
6. If a cell is dismantled is it still 'life'?
6. If man put together parts of a cell that had been dismantled and it 'lives', has he made life from non-life? If not, why not?
7. Is a multicellular organism 'life' as a whole, or only the individual cells. Is a bit of your skin that you scrape off, but still has living human cells 'life'? At what point can it be declared 'dead' or 'non-life'?