Go back
Photo of a “round” earth

Photo of a “round” earth

Spirituality

Vote Up
Vote Down

If the earth is flat, why are there no stories of people falling off the edge?

If the earth is flat, why are there no Edge of the Earth theme parks or tourist spots? Just imagine the view!


@bigdogg said
If the earth is flat, why are there no stories of people falling off the edge?

If the earth is flat, why are there no Edge of the Earth theme parks or tourist spots? Just imagine the view!
Wouldn't there be crooked real estate agents trying to sell land on the underneath?




@ghost-of-a-duke said
The writers themselves would have believed the Earth was flat. (Hence why we have the devil taking Jesus to a high mountain and being able to show him all the kingdoms of the world. - Impossible with a spherical Earth).

Anyone alive today who believes the Earth is flat will rightly receive a raised eyebrow, but in biblical times everybody who existed would have thought the Earth was flat and viewed the idea of a spherical Earth as crazy.
No, not everyone did. Eratosthenes knew it was a globe and even estimated it's size, to within a fair tolerance, given the technology available to him at the time.

https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2018EGUGA..20.5417K/abstract


@bigdogg said
If the earth is flat, why are there no stories of people falling off the edge?

If the earth is flat, why are there no Edge of the Earth theme parks or tourist spots? Just imagine the view!
Because when you fall off, you don't survive to tell the story. DUH!


😆


sonship used to insist that not all ancient Hebrews were flat-Earthers.


@fmf said
sonship used to insist that not all ancient Hebrews were flat-Earthers.
Well, let's just say that some people's mental horizon is broader than others'. It is probable that other ancient people(s) than Eratosthenes realised that the Earth is a globe. Wouldn't surprise me if some Babylonians knew it as well, as they were dedicated observers of the stars. And some ancient sailers probably figured it out too, since the night sky has different constellations in the northern and southern hemispheres; this is inexplicable on the hypothesis of a flat disc; it makes sense only when you know the Earth is a globe.


@fmf said
Wouldn't there be crooked real estate agents trying to sell land on the underneath?
Transfer 1200 pounds to my numbered Swiss bank account, and I'll deed you 1200 sq-cms of land under any country of your choice. (Mineral rights are extra.)

😆

Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
No, not everyone did. Eratosthenes knew it was a globe and even estimated it's size, to within a fair tolerance, given the technology available to him at the time.

https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2018EGUGA..20.5417K/abstract
Good point. I'll replace 'everybody who existed' with 'almost everybody who existed, including almost certainly the various writers of the bible.'

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
The writers of the bible believed the Earth was flat. Most contemporary Christians do not. This is a problem if they are to assert the bible is divinely inspired, as surely the writers would have been inspired to reference the Earth's spherical nature. The bible is also riddled with other scientific inaccuracies.

1 edit

@ghost-of-a-duke said
The writers of the bible believed the Earth was flat. Most contemporary Christians do not. This is a problem if they are to assert the bible is divinely inspired, as surely the writers would have been inspired to reference the Earth's spherical nature. The bible is also riddled with other scientific inaccuracies.
Kindly transfer 1200 pounds to my numbered Swiss bank account and I will gladly expunge the scientific inaccuracies from the Bible for you. I'm feeling inspired today.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
Kindly transfer 1200 pounds to my numbered Swiss bank account and I will gladly expunge the scientific inaccuracies from the Bible for you. I'm feeling inspired today.
Would you accept payment in cooking apples? I seem to currently have an abundance.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@ghost-of-a-duke said
Would you accept payment in cooking apples? I seem to currently have an abundance.
If your wife delivers them personally, yes.


@moonbus said
If your wife delivers them personally, yes.
We have a chap for that, living in the garage.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.