22 Aug '07 08:47>1 edit
Originally posted by twhiteheadGiven a choice between A and B what is the 'reason' for choosing A? You have already stated that on a rerun of the experiment with identical conditions you might choose B. So what is the 'reason'? Answer that or accept that your choice is random. WHITEY
Well maybe you can explain how something that is not caused has meaning? The words meaning, reason etc imply causation. You claim there is no cause but there is meaning and reasons. You are just contradicting yourself over and over.
[b]This is not an appropriate description for God. Self determined and self sufficient causation independent of any exter might choose B. So what is the 'reason'? Answer that or accept that your choice is random.
There is absolutely no obligation on my to accept your two alternatives as being the only two alternatives possible until you prove your premise. You might as well say that I must accept I am wrong because I am wrong.
I have already said that what you regard as self evident is not to me. The reason why one would choose A is the reasons associated with A and if I choose B then likewise. You are unable to conceive of a reasoned choice that is not causally forced by some causal agent . I am able to do this. A reasoned choice that is not causally determined or forced is not an option that you will consider but you continue to express your view as self evident without being honest enough to say that you cannot prove it.
I am free to choose A or B for the reasons that are attached to A or B. I may choose A on one occasion because by an effort of will I decide to surrender to God's will. On another occasion I may not surrender and go my own way (B). Both these options are really open to me (which is what makes it a real choice not a pseudo choice) and I am responsible for either choice based on my own will and my own efforts (eg- I cannot blame forced causation for my actions or say that I was "determined" to do what I did - it's down to me and me only). The reason for me to choose A or B is because I willed either A or B. The rationale for the choice A or B is contained within A and B themselves.