Religious morality Vs atheistic morality

I think it safe to say morality from biblical sources is somewhat like morality from other religions like Islam or Bahai or hindu or Buddhism.

The thing any single religion says is their religion is THE correct religion.

So all of these religions can't be right, some of them have to be man made and only YOUR religion is true.

This kind of thinking can be applied to ALL of these religions, from their viewpoint, a DEITY set up the rules of morality and so forth.

Considering they all say stuff like don't kill, don't steal, leave your buddy's wife alone, honor your mom and dad, etc., it seems if you accept only YOUR religion as having been inspired by a deity, how come all the OTHER religions have similar morality rules?

Could it somehow be that NONE of them were inspired by a deity but simply most human cultures, being composed of more or less intelligent people, comes up with similar mores and such and therefore they ALL just made up these religions out of thin air?

The thing that gripes me about the religious set is the idea that Atheists are somehow floundering around unable to come up with their own moral code.

I think it is just the opposite. Since there are hundreds of religions around the world, each one thinking THEIRS is THE religion, THEY are the ones floundering around trying to come up with moral codes.

It never seems to dawn on people that humans are quite capable of figuring out it is not nice to kill your grandma or steal from your brother or sister and by extension don't steal from anyone.

Why is that such a huge deal that humans can't work that out on their own without the need for a deity to tell them.

It seems to me to denigrate human intelligence to REQUIRE a deity to tell us what is good and what is not.

Originally posted by sonhouse
I think it safe to say morality from biblical sources is somewhat like morality from other religions like Islam or Bahai or hindu or Buddhism.

The thing any single religion says is their religion is THE correct religion.

So all of these religions can't be right, some of them have to be man made and only YOUR religion is true.

This kind of thinking ...[text shortened]... o me to denigrate human intelligence to REQUIRE a deity to tell us what is good and what is not.

",..how come all the OTHER religions have similar morality rules?"

Ever wonder why the major religions have basically the same story of the origin of life? The knowledge of a creator was universally know by all civilizations from the beginning. The problem is is that the story takes on twists and turns as time goes by, but the fundamentals of morality remain basically the same because morality ensures survival and positive development.

The reason why Biblical morality, and the whole story contained therein is the correct one, is because it was delivered to a select group of individuals inspired by God.

How do I know this is true? In the same way you would know it's true, but you've already made up your mind that it isn't, so you can't, that is unless you really want to know, then you will first have to admit to yourself you need a saviour.

Do you want to die, or live forever?

Originally posted by josephw
[b]",..how come all the OTHER religions have similar morality rules?"

Ever wonder why the major religions have basically the same story of the origin of life? The knowledge of a creator was universally know by all civilizations from the beginning. The problem is is that the story takes on twists and turns as time goes by, but the fundamentals of moral ...[text shortened]... will first have to admit to yourself you need a saviour.

Do you want to die, or live forever?[/b]

There's something in what you've posted I'm interested in. I started to get the impression of this in an exchange with sonship in another recent thread. Your case seems to be that all humans secretly know God exists, created the universe and so forth, and that this is a priori knowledge and that atheists are in denial of this?

Originally posted by DeepThought
Your case seems to be that all humans secretly know God exists, created the universe and so forth, and that this is a priori knowledge and that atheists are in denial of this?

A poster called FreakyKBH ~ who used to post quite a lot ~ seemed to believe this was the case.

Originally posted by DeepThought
There's something in what you've posted I'm interested in. I started to get the impression of this in an exchange with sonship in another recent thread. Your case seems to be that all humans secretly know God exists, created the universe and so forth, and that this is a priori knowledge and that atheists are in denial of this?

If we are to believe that, then on what basis do we make that conclusion?

We base it on the authority of the Word of God. Certainly no mere mortal has such authority.

If the "Truth" isn't of Devine origin, then who is there to believe? Do we believe some man when he tells us "there is no God", based on his own authority? Or even that there is a creator God?

There's only one we can believe with absolute confidence. But that's just me saying that!

I hope I answered your question satisfactorily.

Originally posted by josephw
If we are to believe that, then on what basis do we make that conclusion?

We base it on the authority of the Word of God. Certainly no mere mortal has such authority.

If the "Truth" isn't of Devine origin, then who is there to believe? Do we believe some man when he tells us "there is no God", based on his own authority? Or even that there [b]is a ...[text shortened]... e confidence. But that's just me saying that!

I hope I answered your question satisfactorily.[/b]

This is probably worth a separate thread. I think I'll start one.

Originally posted by FMF
A poster called FreakyKBH ~ who used to post quite a lot ~ seemed to believe this was the case.

We base that conclusion, that God is obvious, on Romans 1:19, 20.

Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed [it] unto them.
For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, [even] his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:

God is known(to exist)because it is "clearly seen" and "understood by" what exists.

No excuses!

Originally posted by DeepThought
This is probably worth a separate thread. I think I'll start one.

I'll do my best to be engaged, but my postings may be sporadic as I am quite busy with a full schedule. 🙁

Originally posted by josephw
I'll do my best to be engaged, but my postings may be sporadic as I am quite busy with a full schedule. 🙁

No problem, the thread I started is: Thread 163560

Originally posted by josephw
We base that conclusion, that God is obvious, on Romans 1:19, 20.

Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed [it] unto them.
For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, [even] his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excu ...[text shortened]... d is known(to exist)because it is "clearly seen" and "understood by" what exists.

No excuses!

So you believe that all people secretly (or otherwise) "know" that the Christian God exists?

Originally posted by DeepThought
There's something in what you've posted I'm interested in. I started to get the impression of this in an exchange with sonship in another recent thread. Your case seems to be that all humans secretly know God exists, created the universe and so forth, and that this is a priori knowledge and that atheists are in denial of this?

I'm not all surprised that we all share many of the same ideas on what is
right and wrong, I think you'd be hard pressed to find some ideas that are
completely different such as where loyalty is thought of as bad and being
a traitor is highly prized. Scripturally speaking we all know:

Romans 2:14

(Indeed, when Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law, they are a law for themselves, even though they do not have the law.

Originally posted by FMF
So you believe that all people secretly (or otherwise) "know" that the Christian God exists?

That is basically what scripture says. So you have free will to believe it or not. 😏

Originally posted by RJHinds
That is basically what scripture says. So you have free will to believe it or not. 😏

I don't for one minute think that what Christian scripture just so happens to say ~ which affects what you claim to "know" ~ has any actual effect on what non-Christians (similarly) "know" and believe. The suggestion that all theists everywhere somehow, on some level, "know" the Christians are right is as ludicrous as ugly Brit and American tourists shouting slowly at local natives in English because they believe that 'deep down' all humans understand English. 😉

Originally posted by KellyJay
...I think you'd be hard pressed to find some ideas that are
completely different such as where loyalty is thought of as bad and being
a traitor is highly prized...

Loyalty to an oppressive dictator may look bad in most people's eyes, and betraying said dictator may look good in most people's eyes.

I hope.

Originally posted by josephw

Do you want to die, or live forever?

Living forever is a frightening prospect if you think about it