17 Sep '07 07:08>2 edits
Recently, a friend on here described my view of things (as he sees it) as being “incredibly nihilistic: all meaning gobbled up by the posited ‘ground of all being’ at the center of your [my] idea of reality.”
All “meaning”—“gobbled up”?
I don’t know what that—means!
_____________________________________
I have moved his statement here, rather than simply posing the question to him, because I have been asking for some time now—in the face of similar statements—“What do you mean by ‘meaning’?”. I have yet to get an answer that, to me, makes sense of such a statement. From anyone.
Now, whether or not my philosophical view is one in which “meaning” is gobbled up, I don’t know. Because I don’t know what that word “meaning” means in such a context. And it gets used a lot on here, in similar fashion. (For example, “If there is nothing after death, then life has no ‘meaning’.” Again, I haven’t the slightest clue—really!—what such a statement means.)
To those of you who use the word “meaning” in such a context, I have a request—
Please describe to me how you are using that word. Don’t simply make further assertions about what “has meaning” and what doesn’t—explain to me the use of that word in such contexts. Then I might understand what you are talking about...(which is what I mean by "meaning" ).
All “meaning”—“gobbled up”?
I don’t know what that—means!
_____________________________________
I have moved his statement here, rather than simply posing the question to him, because I have been asking for some time now—in the face of similar statements—“What do you mean by ‘meaning’?”. I have yet to get an answer that, to me, makes sense of such a statement. From anyone.
Now, whether or not my philosophical view is one in which “meaning” is gobbled up, I don’t know. Because I don’t know what that word “meaning” means in such a context. And it gets used a lot on here, in similar fashion. (For example, “If there is nothing after death, then life has no ‘meaning’.” Again, I haven’t the slightest clue—really!—what such a statement means.)
To those of you who use the word “meaning” in such a context, I have a request—
Please describe to me how you are using that word. Don’t simply make further assertions about what “has meaning” and what doesn’t—explain to me the use of that word in such contexts. Then I might understand what you are talking about...(which is what I mean by "meaning" ).