Originally posted by Wulebgr
Don't you see how that sounds a bit presumptuous?
Nevertheless, for the sake of argument, let's say that we accept the authority of the Christian texts as certified by God. If we also consider the Qur'an in the same terms, we find some contradictions in the self-revealtion of God. How do we decide the relative merits of the competing claims?
I submit t ...[text shortened]... stian.
* I don't know this about you--I'm making an assumption for the sake of argument.
Presumptuous, to a fault. There are those who accept all that the church (RCC or otherwise) has posited, since the time of the apostles, hook, line and sinker, without a second thought to veracity. Unlike some who question even the questions, they rest firmly in their trust of greater minds hashing out the bigger things, to (what they believe are) good results.
There are others who want to know why they believe what they are told to believe, as their trust in man is limited. They 'search the Scriptures daily, to see if these things are so,' constantly second-guessing their first guesses, never resting. Emphatically, again, never resting.
There are some in the creases in between.
This is a simplified view of the church, orthodox Christian, and spectrums of varying degrees of the same.
In juxtaposition, anything outside of the Christian perspective is in opposition of the truth. You are asking to hold as equal something not equal to the Word of God. We should expect to see contradictions. You rightly assume that merits must be considered to determine the veracity of the competing claims. And the beauty of the concept of human freedom is this: each of us
gets to determine our own faith and fate.
I think you are almost absolutely correct in your submission. Environment, however, is not everything, and this is where your submission loses ground. There are a plethora of examples from either society of those darting over to the 'other side's' faith. Plenty of examples of Muslims turning to Jesus, and Christians renouncing their roots to adopt the way of the Qu'ran. Just as in a democracy, it really means... not a lot. Each person's vote is just each person's vote. Nothing man does can change gravity's pull to the earth on all falling bodies. Truth is truth.
I think the accident of my birth is really no accident at all (unless you ask my dad!): I was born in the US where Christianity is dominant, only because God knew I wasn't strong enough to fight any other tides to get to the truth.