Go back
This old chestnut, again

This old chestnut, again

Spirituality




-Removed-
Ah I see. You just don't like the term to be used to describe something that's not of the numinous. Fair enough. Just semantics though, isn't it?



-Removed-
With humans, it is all about the brain, but consciousness is the inner subjective experience of what it feels like to see blue or smell petrol or hear Beethoven. Consciousness has baffled and intrigued philosophers for centuries and can not simply be labeled as the natural functioning of the brain. Consciousness 'is' spirit.


-Removed-
Hmm... how do you feel about soul music? Soul food? Spirit of the Radio by Rush?


1 edit


-Removed-
Oh it's certainly not non-sequiturial. You maintain that you dislike usage of the term 'spiritual' in prosaic contexts. I wondered how you felt about the terms 'soul' and 'spirit'. Do you see now that it is indeed sequiturial? My point is as stated previously. It's a semantic argument. A lively horse is 'spirited'. Language is soft. I find the use of the term 'jealous' where the user in fact is talking of 'envy' to be quite irritating, but in language, usage determines meaning. Nowadays it is considered 'correct' to use the term 'literally' entirely incorrectly. Meanings of words wander.

1 edit

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
I understand, and even agree somewhat. I recall when I first started to study critical theory how incensing I found the subject because of the seemingly constant stream of terms reapplied to new contexts. It made it very difficult for me to discuss the subject with those whose advice I sought. Actually I'm still a bit ratty about that.


-Removed-
It's as if you didn't read my reply. (Or lacked the mental capacity to understand it).



-Removed-
My work is outreach. I take my spirit out every day into the community.


Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.