06 Mar '08 17:16>
Originally posted by PsychoPawnIf god knows what you will choose then you have no choice, it doesn't matter whether it's Hitler, Stalin, you or me.
If god knows what you will choose then you have no choice, it doesn't matter whether it's Hitler, Stalin, you or me.
If your decision is known before you make it then your decision isn't truly determined by you - it's determined by god and hence you don't have free will, you only have the illusion of free will in your mind.
[i]You know Hitler's fut ...[text shortened]... If he decided something other than what I knew, then I didn't actually know his choices.
If your decision is known before you make it then your decision isn't truly determined by you ---------PSYCHOPAWN
RESPONSE------
Yes , yes , so you keep saying but where's your proof? You know what Hitler has chosen to do in 1945 but does that prove that what he chose was determined? All you know is that he made a choice (determined or otherwise). You know his future . How does that prove he had no free will?