Originally posted by twhitehead
I think LemonJello has him pegged. Freaky sees himself as a sort of teacher leading the forum through a lesson by means of the Socratic method. He is not the first poster to see himself that way. The problem however is that effective use of the Socratic method requires the teacher to actually make some sense as well as the students doing what they are tol ...[text shortened]... some master point to be made but no way to actually make a point and still maintain his dignity.
Great summary, except for the content.
Freaky sees himself as a sort of teacher leading the forum through a lesson by means of the Socratic method.
You literally have no idea how I see myself; claiming otherwise is sheer arrogance, nothing more.
The origination of the thread was an underlying basic question: what difference does it make for a man to believe something which otherwise has no bearing on his life or well-being?
When everyone went off script and what Freaky thought was general ignorance of a subject turned out to be a case of just his own ignorance of the subject he found himself trapped in a situation he does not know how to get out of.
Off script, as in response number one, when Ghost of a Duke referenced the coming alien invasion of June 08, 2089?
The general ignorance of the subject has been gloriously on display by those supposedly all in agreement: replete with many false claims; self-contradiction; outright refusal to accept obvious facts; attacks on the person; and other follies too numerous to name.
He is therefore left with hinting at some master point to be made but no way to actually make a point and still maintain his dignity.
The "master point" is the 600 plus posts to the thread.
Although there were a few posts (less than a handful) which actually addressed the question, the lot of you who were in such disagreement with the hypothetical (however poorly understood and pathetically supported), you became so embroiled with the hypothetical you couldn't address the first question.
By doing so, you (in my opinion) accidentally answered the question even though you're unable to show your work.
It is very important, we just don't know why.