Go back
Was Jona swallowed by a whale?

Was Jona swallowed by a whale?

Spirituality

dj2becker

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
Clock
11 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

A certain atheistic teacher was teaching evolution to his class. He explained that after millions of years of evolution it is impossible for a whale to swallow a human being.

A little girl stood up and asked whether the whale in the Bible really swallowed Jona. The teacher said that she shouldn't believe in the Bible, because it's only a fairy tale. The little girl said that one day when she got to heaven she would ask Jona if he really got swallowed by a whale. The teacher asked what she would do if Jona was not in heaven. The girl replied that the teacher could then ask him in the other place.

P
Mystic Meg

tinyurl.com/3sbbwd4

Joined
27 Mar 03
Moves
17242
Clock
11 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dj2becker
A certain atheistic teacher was teaching evolution to his class. He explained that after millions of years of evolution it is impossible for a whale to swallow a human being.

A little girl stood up and asked whether the whale in the Bible really swallowed Jona. The teacher said that she shouldn't believe in the Bible, because it's only a fairy tale. T ...[text shortened]... Jona was not in heaven. The girl replied that the teacher could then ask him in the other place.
I must admit I like this one, and the 'Golden Tar' joke.

ES

N
The eyes of truth

elsewhere

Joined
26 Apr 04
Moves
21784
Clock
11 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dj2becker
A certain atheistic teacher was teaching evolution to his class. He explained that after millions of years of evolution it is impossible for a whale to swallow a human being.

A little girl stood up and asked whether the whale in the Bible really swallowed Jona. The teacher said that she shouldn't believe in the Bible, because it's only a fairy tale. T ...[text shortened]... Jona was not in heaven. The girl replied that the teacher could then ask him in the other place.
🙂

I like this.

t
King of the Ashes

Trying to rise ....

Joined
16 Jun 04
Moves
63851
Clock
11 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dj2becker
A certain atheistic teacher was teaching evolution to his class. He explained that after millions of years of evolution it is impossible for a whale to swallow a human being.

A little girl stood up and asked whether the whale in the Bible really swallowed Jona. The teacher said that she shouldn't believe in the Bible, because it's only a fairy tale. T ...[text shortened]... Jona was not in heaven. The girl replied that the teacher could then ask him in the other place.
It was a giant fish, not a whale.

... --- ...

R
Acts 13:48

California

Joined
21 May 03
Moves
227555
Clock
11 May 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dj2becker
A certain atheistic teacher was teaching evolution to his class. He explained that after millions of years of evolution it is impossible for a whale to swallow a human being.

A little girl stood up and asked whether the whale in the Bi ...[text shortened]... rl replied that the teacher could then ask him in the other place.
I heard that one before, sad but true statement.

N
The eyes of truth

elsewhere

Joined
26 Apr 04
Moves
21784
Clock
11 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by thesonofsaul
It was a giant fish, not a whale.

... --- ...
And your proof for this?

Or have you been reading the nkjv?

Ketos is the greek for whale. The scientific study of whales is cetology. The greek version had ketos. Fish is a different word.

t
King of the Ashes

Trying to rise ....

Joined
16 Jun 04
Moves
63851
Clock
11 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nyxie
And your proof for this?

Or have you been reading the nkjv?

Ketos is the greek for whale. The scientific study of whales is cetology. The greek version had ketos. Fish is a different word.
My mistake then. I recalled my childhood studies saying that Jonah was swallowed by a giant fish.

... --- ...

BigDogg
Secret RHP coder

on the payroll

Joined
26 Nov 04
Moves
155080
Clock
11 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dj2becker
A certain atheistic teacher was teaching evolution to his class. He explained that after millions of years of evolution it is impossible for a whale to swallow a human being.

A little girl stood up and asked whether the whale in the Bible really swallowed Jona. The teacher said that she shouldn't believe in the Bible, because it's only a fairy tale. T ...[text shortened]... Jona was not in heaven. The girl replied that the teacher could then ask him in the other place.
The teacher should respond, "Listen sweetie. If a prophet of God can't even make it into heaven, you're screwed."

dj2becker

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
12095
Clock
12 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by BigDoggProblem
The teacher should respond, "Listen sweetie. If a prophet of God can't even make it into heaven, you're screwed."
The child would respond, "How do you know he is not in Heaven?"

BigDogg
Secret RHP coder

on the payroll

Joined
26 Nov 04
Moves
155080
Clock
12 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by dj2becker
The child would respond, "How do you know he is not in Heaven?"

No, she wouldn't, because her little joke just admitted the possibility of Jonah going to hell. (And what a presumptuous little brat to assume the teacher is going to hell!)

L

Joined
10 May 05
Moves
36716
Clock
13 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by BigDoggProblem
No, she wouldn't, because her little joke just admitted the possibility of Jonah going to hell. (And what a presumptuous little brat to assume the teacher is going to hell!)
I think someone is taking this joke a little to seriously, I think its rather funny, jokes arent meant to be analized to much.... :-)

f
Bruno's Ghost

In a hot place

Joined
11 Sep 04
Moves
7707
Clock
13 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by thesonofsaul
My mistake then. I recalled my childhood studies saying that Jonah was swallowed by a giant fish.

... --- ...
For the record you are right ! it's "giant fish".

N
The eyes of truth

elsewhere

Joined
26 Apr 04
Moves
21784
Clock
13 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by frogstomp
For the record you are right ! it's "giant fish".

Don't just assert, prove please. Thank you.

Nyxie

x

NY

Joined
29 Mar 05
Moves
1152
Clock
13 May 05
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nyxie
Don't just assert, prove please. Thank you.

Nyxie
http://www.thercg.org/questions/p134.a.html


http://www.olivebranch.com/biblestories/jonah.htm


http://www.virtualchurch.org/jonah.htm

no1marauder
Naturally Right

Somewhere Else

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
42677
Clock
13 May 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Nyxie
Don't just assert, prove please. Thank you.

Nyxie
Jonah 1: 17 uses a "great fish" in all the versions I can find. Interestingly, though, when Jesus says the Son of Man will be in the Earth for three days just as Jonah was in -------, the American Standard Version and the King James Version use "whale" in Matthew 12:40. I wonder if the ancient Hebrews even knew what a whale was.
For a bunch of versions of the Bible go to: http://www.biblegateway.com/

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.