- Joined
- 29 Dec 08
- Moves
- 6788
02 Jul 13
Originally posted by wolfgang59Afaics, the nonexistent UCA approves of your dislocations. Their nonexistent scriptures say, Let him who will be loosened up, loosen up. Let the tight remain tight.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/21/yoga-school-program_n_2733444.html
My GP recommended yoga classes to me ... I didn't realise I was risking
being thrown out of the United Church of Atheism for dislocating my limbs!
02 Jul 13
Originally posted by wolfgang59No, yoga is not a religion. Seems there is much misunderstanding as to the differences between personal religion, organized religion, spirituality (be it personal or group), nature let alone god.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/21/yoga-school-program_n_2733444.html
My GP recommended yoga classes to me ... I didn't realise I was risking
being thrown out of the United Church of Atheism for dislocating my limbs!
- Joined
- 31 May 06
- Moves
- 1795
02 Jul 13
Originally posted by wolfgang59I don't know if anyone here actually does yoga and could answer this question...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/21/yoga-school-program_n_2733444.html
My GP recommended yoga classes to me ... I didn't realise I was risking
being thrown out of the United Church of Atheism for dislocating my limbs!
Does yoga normally involve believing in/being told about "spiritual energy" or souls,
afterlives, gods, or anything supernatural?
If it simply involves exercise and meditation then it's not religious... even if it originated
in a religion.
Even if it does normally involve belief in the supernatural, I don't think it would qualify
as a religious activity if these kids are only doing the exercise/meditation aspects of it.
Perhaps in the same way that giving presents, having a tree and decorations at Christmas,
are not in of themselves inherently religious activities.
If the exercise regime of yoga has health benefits, and the meditation helps relax and focus
the kids then I don't see a problem. As long as they are not given any supernatural baggage
to go along with it.
02 Jul 13
Originally posted by googlefudgeI believe it varies. But I (briefly) went to a yoga class and there wasn't anything more spiritual than meditation involved. No talk about spiritual energies or souls or anything like that.
I don't know if anyone here actually does yoga and could answer this question...
Does yoga normally involve believing in/being told about "spiritual energy" or souls,
afterlives, gods, or anything supernatural?
If it simply involves exercise and meditation then it's not religious... even if it originated
in a religion.
Even if it does normal ...[text shortened]... e a problem. As long as they are not given any supernatural baggage
to go along with it.
03 Jul 13
Originally posted by VartiovuoriI went to yoga classes in the UK and it was purely exercise - no meditation
I believe it varies. But I (briefly) went to a yoga class and there wasn't anything more spiritual than meditation involved. No talk about spiritual energies or souls or anything like that.
involved at all. Perhaps yoga has different connotations in the US?
04 Jul 13
Originally posted by googlefudgeI do my own yoga when I feel like it. I know some basic positions that are commonly taught.
I don't know if anyone here actually does yoga and could answer this question...
Does yoga normally involve believing in/being told about "spiritual energy" or souls,
afterlives, gods, or anything supernatural?
If it simply involves exercise and meditation then it's not religious... even if it originated
in a religion.
Even if it does normal ...[text shortened]... e a problem. As long as they are not given any supernatural baggage
to go along with it.
I dont see it as requiring any religion behind it. I just see everything as spiritual, especially the things that my mind/body wants to do. After some practice, it's not hard to feel that my mind/body wants to do some yoga type exercises. Good for the circulation and keeps the synapses firing well.
04 Jul 13
Originally posted by wolfgang59It is a vital component of Vedic custom. Many if not most yoga manuals are derived from age old vedic (Hindu) literature.
I went to yoga classes in the UK and it was purely exercise - no meditation
involved at all. Perhaps yoga has different connotations in the US?
- Joined
- 31 May 06
- Moves
- 1795
04 Jul 13
Originally posted by karoly aczelYeah but the Kamasutra is also a religious work...
It is a vital component of Vedic custom. Many if not most yoga manuals are derived from age old vedic (Hindu) literature.
Yet most people nowadays wouldn't think that you are engaging in a religious
ritual by following it...
Or maybe they do...
04 Jul 13
Originally posted by googlefudgeYes, I agree. most semi-intelligent people understand that yoga is just yoga. but it does come from a tradtition where physical well being was considered as important as spiritual well being.
Yeah but the Kamasutra is also a religious work...
Yet most people nowadays wouldn't think that you are engaging in a religious
ritual by following it...
Or maybe they do...