Originally posted by USArmyParatrooper
Is having a fist full of jersey legal, yes or no?
Crabree was trying to push him away to get him to let go of his grip. That doesn't suddenly make grabbing the jersey LEGAL. IF you want to call that too then it's off setting penalties and the play is reset.
The ball would have been catchable had Crabree not been held. But that doesn't matte ...[text shortened]... Crabree was being held before the ball even got there. It should have at least been holding.
Remember you're watching it in slow mo.
1. Mutual contact
2. The contact is initiated within five yards and they're just a split second away or a couple steps into the endzone when the defender falls over and the ball was snapped on the five so he does have his jersey past the five yard mark barely but crabtree is pushing off... You keep saying that he can push to get him off but the defender cant hold on if he's getting pushed?
3. Crabtree's next step, as the ball sails over his reach has his foot out of bounds so the ball is way uncatchable.
4. A play where there was mutual contact, if you call both penalties and the play resets you are still penalizing the defense on a ball that was way over the hands of crabtree even when he was already stepping out of bounds... Good no call.
5. You know it was uncatchable because there was another defender who had free range and would have intercepted a catchable pass if Crabtree missed it but the ball landed far out of bounds and was zipped really fast and high... There was no way he was gonna catch that in bounds.