Originally posted by no1marauder
Expecting the Iranians to pass such information within their entire civilian infrastructure in 4 minutes is unrealistic and absurd. As 9-11 showed, the US could not get reliable information from its civilian air sector to its military sector and vice versa in anywhere near such a time frame. In fact, the US ships involved could not get information passed nes fired. It seems you are using two very different standards to judge Iranian and US actions.
A couple things of note here, because I finally had time to read the article you posted.
(IF) Captain Carlson's accounts of events are accurate, which at this point I don't have reason to disbelieve, I agree that Captain Rogers should have been relieved of duty at the very least.
With that being said, the crews of
both ships believed the plane to be an F-14 right up until the moment the missile was fired. The difference was CPT Carlson rightly believed it to be behaving in a manner inconsistent with hostile intent.
Indeed, as Captain Carlson would learn minutes after the Airbus plummeted into the water, the electronic specialists in the Sides' combat information center had correctly identified the aircraft's commercial transponder code at virtually the same instant that the Vincennes fired her missiles.
"And this is where I take some responsibility for this mess. If I had been smarter, if I had said it doesn't smell like an F-14, and pushed for a re-evaluation, and if my guys had come forward, saying that's an IFF squawk for a haj [Islamic pilgrim] flight, I might have been stimulated to go back to Rogers and say, 'It looks like you've got COMAIR here."
I never suggested they inform the entire population, but certainly local airports would be a priority. By the time the order was given to fire the missile the fighting had been going on for 11 minutes (according to records). What's more, the Iranians knew the situation was getting heated long before a shot was fired, given the fact that they had deployed multiple gun boats to that area. Their military
should have established restricted airspace in that region until things cooled off.