Go back
Blaming Trump for unconstitutional acts

Blaming Trump for unconstitutional acts

Debates


Ok, so the Defense Secretary has apparently violated the constitution multiple times... how is he defending himself against this accusation?

They were just following orders. He blames Trump. And the Attorney General also blamed Trump. The Secretary of State... also used the "just following orders" line made famous from the Nuremburg trials.

Here are all the quotes from today. Hegseth, Blanche, Rubio. All his cabinet marching out and saying that if they violated the constitution then it's because they were ordered by the Commander in Chief.

https://x.com/atrupar/status/2120143964716126506

https://x.com/atrupar/status/2120163534453522941

https://x.com/atrupar/status/2120153199705260218

Vote Up
Vote Down

How far does this go? Should every person in the chain of command get held responsible?

Are the U.S. soldiers who went to Iraq also war criminals with Bush?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@vivify said
How far does this go? Should every person in the chain of command get held responsible?

Are the U.S. soldiers who went to Iraq also war criminals with Bush?
Did you read the impeachment documents? It's pretty specific.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/10/us/politics/hegseth-impeachment-explainer-massie.html


@vivify said
How far does this go? Should every person in the chain of command get held responsible?

Are the U.S. soldiers who went to Iraq also war criminals with Bush?
Impeachment is a civil procedure to remove an official from office. The only penalties are that removal and ineligibility for future Federal office.

Soldiers are not required to follow illegal orders and "I was following orders" is not a defense if the order is manifestly illegal. However in military law there is a presumption that orders are legal and service members disobey them at their own peril. A specific discussion by an ex-military lawyer is here: https://www.ucmjlaw.com/disobey-a-superior-officer/

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
Impeachment is a civil procedure to remove an official from office. The only penalties are that removal and ineligibility for future Federal office.

Soldiers are not required to follow illegal orders and "I was following orders" is not a defense if the order is manifestly illegal. However in military law there is a presumption that orders are legal and service members ...[text shortened]... fic discussion by an ex-military lawyer is here: https://www.ucmjlaw.com/disobey-a-superior-officer/
Do you think this might happen? Will the MAGA wall break before the new congress is seated? I just heard Joni Ernst saying she might vote to impeach. Probably they're just putting a little pressure on the administration to fire Hegseth so they don't have to impeach him.

It seems like they're all blaming everyone except themselves.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@no1marauder said
Impeachment is a civil procedure to remove an official from office. The only penalties are that removal and ineligibility for future Federal office.

Soldiers are not required to follow illegal orders and "I was following orders" is not a defense if the order is manifestly illegal. However in military law there is a presumption that orders are legal and service members ...[text shortened]... fic discussion by an ex-military lawyer is here: https://www.ucmjlaw.com/disobey-a-superior-officer/
Thank you.