Go back
Karmelo Anthony Guilty Verdict

Karmelo Anthony Guilty Verdict

Debates


@Mott-The-Hoople said
No, this is where you liberal woke mfers fail the black community. All your victim BS had this Anthony kid thinking he could do anything and he would escape punishment because he is black.

Many blacks on the street now raising hell because of a correct outcome.

Quit leading these people into situations such as this with your constant coddling, can do no wrong BS.

This kid found reality.
2nd racial reference in the thread


@AThousandYoung said
This is the first post mentioning race.
Racism dumbass, not race


@Rajk999 said
Americans, Canadians and some parts of the west are very tolerant of black criminals. They are afraid of being called racist, nazi, fascist etc. Where I live, most of the police force are blacks and most of the criminals are blacks, so there is no fear of being called racist. A criminal is often shot and killed long before it reaches the court. A man like Karmelo would be executed on the way to the police station in some kind of gun mishap.
3rd reference to race.

The left aren’t the ones making this about race.


@AThousandYoung said
This is the first post mentioning race.
Old Chinese proverb....Never bait the Suziannes


@no1marauder said
Most of this post is factually incorrect and the bottom line is that if Metcalf and his group had simply left Anthony alone the whole incident wouldn't have happened and they had no legal authority not to leave him alone. And unlike Goetz, it seems highly unlikely Anthony meant to kill. 35 years seems an excessive sentence here.

I agree with the last paragraph of course.
I do tend to agree that 35 years was excessive. At least in New York, this sounds like Man 1 (intent to ccause serious injury) rather than murder. I think a ~ 10-15 year sentence would have been more appropriate.

It still sounds like a homicide to me, though.


@AThousandYoung said
3rd reference to race.

The left aren’t the ones making this about race.
The dumb person doesn’t understand the difference between racism and race.


@mike69 said
I glanced when I said that I still haven’t went back since the topic doesn’t take away from my point. You seem to be sinking in stupidity with yourself to blame.
Since it's destroyed your claim that Anthony was a "wannabe gang member with a gun" I can see why.

Also, you claimed he was a troublemaker, who got into all kinds of fights and wasn't even supposed to be at the meet because of such misconduct. Turns out he had a 3.7 GPA, was scheduled to compete in the long jump that day in the afternoon and was an alternative for the JV team in the morning and rode in with the rest of his teammates on the Centennial bus. So a lot of just plain wrong claims you made apparently based on some unreliable social media posts.

I did make one mistake earlier; I said Metcalf wasn't on the track team and it appears he was. I apologize for that error.

3 edits

@sh76 said
I do tend to agree that 35 years was excessive. At least in New York, this sounds like Man 1 (intent to ccause serious injury) rather than murder. I think a ~ 10-15 year sentence would have been more appropriate.

It still sounds like a homicide to me, though.
We'll see what the Texas appellate courts make of it. I guess he's eligible for parole halfway through the sentence though they do not release those convicted of murder on bond during appeal (don't think they do that much in NY either).

10 years is what Caysen Allison got in a similar Texas case (but he was only convicted of criminally negligent homicide despite inflicting multiple stab wounds):

"What sentence should have Caysen Allison got for stabbing Joe Ramirez multiple times causing his death in a boy's room fight between two teenagers? https://people.com/caysen-allison-texas-school-stabbing-trial-11716268


@no1marauder said
Since it's destroyed your claim that Anthony was a "wannabe gang member with a gun" I can see why.

Also, you claimed he was a troublemaker, who got into all kinds of fights and wasn't even supposed to be at the meet because of such misconduct. Turns out he had a 3.7 GPA, was scheduled to compete in the long jump that day in the afternoon and was an alternative for the ...[text shortened]... earlier; I said Metcalf wasn't on the track team and it appears he was. I apologize for that error.
He had been expelled for the knife in school previously, and fights, not on the team because of these issues, skipped school to go , took a knife, stabbed Austin through the heart into bone in cold blood . All witnesses said many asked to leave, 15 times, just starting trouble. I could go on but it was clear to all and just takes a little research. You are a low IQ dishonest person and activist who will never admit he’s wrong just letting things fade away and moving on. You are 100% pumping bs and lies and you know it, why else act stupid when the facts are clear to see.

3 edits

@mike69 said
He had been expelled for the knife in school previously, and fights, not on the team because of these issues, skipped school to go , took a knife, stabbed Austin through the heart into bone in cold blood . All witnesses said many asked to leave, 15 times, just starting trouble. I could go on but it was clear to all and just takes a little research. You are a low IQ dis ...[text shortened]... u are 100% pumping bs and lies and you know it, why else act stupid when the facts are clear to see.
Complete BS.

"Anthony had a physical therapist appointment for a shoulder injury suffered in football, but opted not to go.

Instead, he drove to school and hopped on the school bus bound for the district's stadium, despite his long-jump events not taking place until that afternoon.

Although during the trial, it was learned that Anthony was an "alternate" for a JV track event that morning."

https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/frisco-track-meet-stabbing-the-tragic-perfect-storm-of-april-2-2025/4035526/

More:

"Teen witnesses were not all in agreement on whether it was common for participants to sit with other teams or under another team's tents; some saw it as normal, while others said they never did or saw this happen."

"The nearest coach was about 20 feet away, according to testimony."

You keep repeating pretty outrageous lies without even trying to substantiate them.


@no1marauder said
Complete BS.

"Anthony had a physical therapist appointment for a shoulder injury suffered in football, but opted not to go.

Instead, he drove to school and hopped on the school bus bound for the district's stadium, despite his long-jump events not taking place until that afternoon.

Although during the trial, it was learned that Anthony was an "alternate" for a JV ...[text shortened]... o testimony."

You keep repeating pretty outrageous lies without even trying to substantiate them.
“You keep repeating pretty outrageous lies without even trying to substantiate them.”

Looking in the mirror?


@sh76 said
I do tend to agree that 35 years was excessive. At least in New York, this sounds like Man 1 (intent to ccause serious injury) rather than murder. I think a ~ 10-15 year sentence would have been more appropriate.

It still sounds like a homicide to me, though.
What do you suppose was his intentions when he armed himself before going to a track meet?


@Mott-The-Hoople said
What do you suppose was his intentions when he armed himself before going to a track meet?
Why do you right wingers keep saying Jan 6 rioters with pocketknives were “unarmed” when they illegally stormed the White House but now you say this guy was armed?


@Mott-The-Hoople said
“You keep repeating pretty outrageous lies without even trying to substantiate them.”

Looking in the mirror?
100%, He doesn’t want the truth. He’s here to mislead the sheep, the truth is simple to find he won’t look.


@mike69 said
100%, He doesn’t want the truth. He’s here to mislead the sheep, the truth is simple to find he won’t look.
Please give a link to a reputable source saying any of the things you claimed that I just debunked by using an article from the local NBC affiliate in Dallas-Fort Worth.

You can't.