Go back
Never Forgive & Never Forget

Never Forgive & Never Forget

Debates


The post that was quoted here has been removed
The Bible is not the reason why Palestinians attacked the Jews on 7th October 2023?

Vote Up
2
Vote Down

1 edit

@Rajk999 said
You have a problem with religion and I never said the Jews have a divine right to Palestine. Also your belief that if Jews or Arabs believe they have a divine right to anything, then that is the reason for failed negotiations. Nonsense.

You have failed to understand the issues.

In 1948, the Arab nations surrounding Palestine said the Jews will never occupy or set up a ...[text shortened]... of Israel in Palestine.

Israel said no such thing.

Yet you keep making excuses for the Arabs.
Yet you keep making excuses for the Arabs.
And vis-versa to you.
The main point of this conflict is, there was NO ISRAEL from 69 A.D. to 1948 A.D. That's 1900+ years. Then in 1948 all the sudden they got their country back; and, they have not be nice, friendly, or loving, to the people whom have been living there for the last 2000 years or so. However, that clearly goes both ways.

Either way, Arabs and Jews are related; period. And, their conflict with each other is due to their religious beliefs. It's in the Bible, read about it.

Goggle AI overview:
a sovereign state called Israel did not exist from 69 A.D. to 1948 A.D. During this roughly 1,900-year period, the geographic region was controlled by a succession of major foreign empires and powers.
The last independent Jewish government in the region prior to the modern era was the ancient Hasmonean Kingdom, which lost its independence after Rome conquered Jerusalem in 63 B.C. Following the Jewish-Roman wars—including the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 A.D. and the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 A.D.—the Romans integrated the region fully into their empire and renamed the province Syria Palaestina.
While a continuous Jewish presence remained in the region throughout history, the land itself was governed sequentially by different empires:
• Roman & Byzantine Empires (Until the 7th Century)
• Islamic Caliphates (Following the 7th-century Muslim conquest)
• The Crusaders (12th and 13th Centuries)
• The Mamluk Sultanate (Until the early 16th Century)
• The Ottoman Empire (1516–1917)
• The British Mandate of Palestine (1917–1948)
The modern State of Israel was officially established on May 14, 1948, following the termination of the British Mandate and the 1947 United Nations partition plan


@no1marauder said
Actually, 65,000 to 90,000 Bedouins lived in the Negev Desert before Israel was created by war in 1948. https://www.hrw.org/reports/2008/iopt0308/3.htm

They did not consent to Zionist conquest and most fled or were driven out of Israel.

65,000 to 90,000 is about the same amount as the number of people who were Jews in pre-WW1 Palestine about 10% to perhaps 14% of the population.
In 1948, some of the Bedouins sided with the Jews and fought with them. These are friends of the Jews.

Some Bedouins sided with the Arabs and after the 1948 war was done, many Arabs and Bedouins ran into neighboring states.

1 edit

@Rajk999 said
In 1948, some of the Bedouins sided with the Jews and fought with them. These are friends of the Jews.

Some Bedouins sided with the Arabs and after the 1948 war was done, many Arabs and Bedouins ran into neighboring states.
Either way, your statement that "nobody wanted" the Negev was factually wrong as most of your statements regarding the creation of Israel are.

The bigger point was the Partition Plan proposed giving the Negev to Israel despite the fact it was almost entirely populated by non-Jews. This is just another example of its gross unfairness and why it was rejected by the representatives of the majority in Palestine.


@KingDavid403 said
Yet you keep making excuses for the Arabs.
Then in 1948 all the sudden they got their country back; and, they have not be nice, friendly, or loving, to the people whom have been living there for the last 2000 years or so.
In Israel there are over 2,000,000 Arabs working, living, participating in politics, in the army. They live happily among Jews, and as equals in the eyes of the law.

In all Arab states all over the world Jews have been expelled, abused, killed, forced to pay jizya, and treated like second class citizens.

So who exactly is not nice, or friendly or loving.

1 edit

@Rajk999 said
In Israel there are over 2,000,000 Arabs working, living, participating in politics, in the army. They live happily among Jews, and as equals in the eyes of the law.

In all Arab states all over the world Jews have been expelled, abused, killed, forced to pay jizya, and treated like second class citizens.

So who exactly is not nice, or friendly or loving.
So who exactly is not nice, or friendly or loving.
Both sides.

In Israel there are over 2,000,000 Arabs working, living, participating in politics, in the army. They live happily among Jews, and as equals in the eyes of the law.
Yes, I'm sure they go to the Mount of Olives together, and tip-toe threw the tulips there together. 🙄


@no1marauder said
Either way, your statement that "nobody wanted" the Negev was factually wrong as most of your statements regarding the creation of Israel are.

The bigger point was the Partition Plan proposed giving the Negev to Israel despite the fact it was almost entirely populated by non-Jews. This is just another example of its gross unfairness and why it was rejected by the representatives of the majority in Palestine.
The Bedouins who remained in the Negev have lived significantly better lives since 1948. They are Israeli citizens, they have access to education, health care and modern infrastructure.

I say they have won. Lucky them. They are far better off than Palestinians in Gaza or in the West Bank.

1 edit

@Rajk999 said
The Bedouins who remained in the Negev have lived significantly better lives since 1948. They are Israeli citizens, they have access to education, health care and modern infrastructure.

I say they have won. Lucky them. They are far better off than Palestinians in Gaza or in the West Bank.
They are Israeli citizens, they have access to education, health care and modern infrastructure.
And don't forget, free abortion care for those women in need of it. 🙂
Or, is that part of the Jewish Religion that you disagree with?

1 edit

@Rajk999 said
On Oct 7th, 2023 approx. 6,000 Palestinian terrorists stormed a small kibbutz in Israel and surrounding area, killing, raping and taking hostages, men women and children. 3 years later 4,000 of these animals have been executed by Israel. 2,000 to go. They will be killed sooner or later.

Here is the story from Claude AI:

*****************************************
This i ...[text shortened]... catastrophe, if you'd like me to go into that side as well.
**************************************
from your own link: Hamas launched "Operation Al-Aqsa Flood,

The Palestinians did not launch this assault. The Hamas are Iranian operatives that are supported by Iran.

There were Israeli children killed by Hamas but Israel cannot kill non-existent Hamas children, so Israel chose to kill innocent Palestinian children instead.

All expected behavior by the butchers of Tel Aviv


@Earl-of-Trumps said
from your own link: Hamas launched "Operation Al-Aqsa Flood,

The Palestinians did not launch this assault. The Hamas are Iranian operatives that are supported by Iran.

There were Israeli children killed by Hamas but Israel cannot kill non-existent Hamas children, so Israel chose to kill innocent Palestinian children instead.

All expected behavior by the butchers of Tel Aviv
We had this disucssion already and you know the whole story. One distasteful character flaw in many people is twisting the truth to suit to support a preconceived belief. You have that.

Gazans support Hamas, and they supported killing of Jews. Gazans hid Hamas operatives in their basements, placed their children in front of Hamas, and supported them. Gazans deserve every bit of death and suffering they endured.

I have no patience with this nonsense. Google this information yourself.

1 edit

@Rajk999 said "One distasteful character flaw in many people is twisting the truth to suit to support a preconceived belief."

I suggest that you stop doing it, then

The information I had came from YOUR link. It was a Hamas initiative. If the Palestinians were to have known, the IDF would have known.


@Earl-of-Trumps said
@Rajk999 said "One distasteful character flaw in many people is twisting the truth to suit to support a preconceived belief."

I suggest that you stop doing it, then

The information I had came from YOUR link. It was a Hamas initiative. If the Palestinians were to have known, the IDF would have known.
Hamas was the elected government of Gaza.
What difference does it make if they knew of the attack or not?


@Rajk999 said
Hamas was the elected government of Gaza.
What difference does it make if they knew of the attack or not?
IDF has paid spies amongst the Palestinians.


@KingDavid403 said
They are Israeli citizens, they have access to education, health care and modern infrastructure.
And don't forget, free abortion care for those women in need of it. 🙂
Or, is that part of the Jewish Religion that you disagree with?
I have no opinion on abortions.