29 Jul '14 21:46>
The post that was quoted here has been removedYes one must always be careful about perceptions for even if the legality can be established it will mean little if its misunderstood.
Originally posted by quackquackKindly bear in mind the content of the first page of posts on this specific thread. By way of comment on events in Gaza, Seitse presented a youtube video of a hight-tech military helicopter in action as though it were an entertaining action game, and a series of others posted offensive, insulting comments which indicated their approval of this tasteless post and made insulting, factually incorrect assertions about the victims in Gaza. These were ATY, RJHinds, Elador, Krod Madoon, normbenign, quackquack.
I certainly understand that if you do not enjoy the conversation that you have better things to do with your time. It is definitely a reasonable position.
I just feel that it is a shame that through verbal abuse of you, your religion and your country, a radical view has hijacked this forum. Anyone who read this discussion (and others on Israel) should ...[text shortened]... ho do not feel like price of expressing their views -- repeated personal attacks -- is worth it.
1036. Samih Ijneid, 4, was killed by tank fire in northern Gaza.Sadly, our source is finding it increasingly difficult to establish names for the victims of the IDF onslaught on Gaza.
1037. Unknown, killed in an attack on a public garden in the Beach refugee camp.
1038. Unknown, was killed in the same attack.
1039. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1040. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1041. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1042. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1043. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1044. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1045. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1046. An unidentified child was killed in the same attack.
1047. Unknown
1048. Unknown
1049. Unknown
1050. Yahya Mohammed Abdallah al-Aaqad, 49, was killed in al-Fakhari.
1051. Maryam Khalil Abed-Rabboh, 70, was killed in an attack in Jabalia.
1052. Hani Abu Khalifa, was killed in the same attack.
1053. Youssef Imad Qaddoura, a child, was killed in the same attack.
1054. Hind Imad Qaddoura, a child, was killed in the same attack.
1055. Mohammed Moussa Aalwan, a child, was killed in the same attack.
Originally posted by sh76http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_Strip#Demographics
You can't possibly believe that using the phrase "final solution to the Palestinian problem" is an appropriate debating tactic.
Gaza has an annual population growth rate of 2.91% (2014 est.), the 13th highest in the world, and is overcrowded.[4][5] There is a limited capability to construct new homes and facilities for this growth. The territory is 41 kilometers (25 mi) long, and from 6 to 12 kilometers (3.7 to 7.5 mi) wide, with a total area of 365 square kilometers (141 sq mi).[6] As of 2014, Palestinians of the Gaza Strip numbered around 1.82 million people.[5] The large Palestinian refugee population makes it among the most densely populated parts of the world.This tiny strip of land is heavily built up and its 1.8 million people have nowhere to go and no way to avoid the large scale, systematic bombing and artillery fire from a modern army which they have no effective weapons to resist.
Originally posted by robbie carrobie
I don't think even the South Africans employed US manufactured drones to systematically murder people by remote control. Or tie their opponents to the front of cars so as to form a human shield.
Or tie their opponents to the front of cars so as to form a human shieldNo, but the British (to our shame) did do that in Palestine.
Originally posted by DeepThoughtThe time period would coincide with the so called Black and Tans in Ireland, made up of sergeants from the WW1 British army. Same generation. Similar tactics. Not nice boys.Or tie their opponents to the front of cars so as to form a human shieldNo, but the British (to our shame) did do that in Palestine.
Originally posted by DeepThoughtI hate to even go down this road because I hate to dignify the comparison by commenting on it. But the difference is more than that. Can anyone point to a single instance when a surrendered Palestinian was executed by an Israeli soldier? Can anyone point to a single instance when a civilian was intentionally killed? Can anyone doubt that, had they the will, Israel could kill most of the people of Gaza with a carpet bombing campaign?
The level of efficiency is rather important. The Nazis rounded up Jews and carted them off to death camps for gassing. The Israelis want the Palestinians to go away for certain, they'll terrorise the population killing a few on the way, but that's not the same as the industrialised systematic murder of the death camps. Comparisons with Apartheid South Africa are more appropriate.
Originally posted by finnegan1,000 deaths or thereabouts out of 1.8 million people is roughly 1/20 of one percent. The operation is in response to thousands of rockets launched at Israeli civilian areas.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_Strip#Demographics[quote]Gaza has an annual population growth rate of 2.91% (2014 est.), the 13th highest in the world, and is overcrowded.[4][5] There is a limited capability to construct new homes and facilities for this growth. The territory is 41 kilometers (25 mi) long, and from 6 to 12 kilometers (3.7 to 7.5 mi) wide, ...[text shortened]... y SH76 but you find better words to capture and to do any justice to the pictures of Gaza today.
Originally posted by finneganI did not mean an "eye for an eye" justification. I don't believe in an eye for an eye.
SH76 entered the discussion with a short post saying that Hamas wanted to totally eliminate the Israelis, which potentially implied a sort of eye for an eye type of justification.
The post that was quoted here has been removedBut you did by implication speak for the gentlemen. sh76 has directly dealt with the issue of the right of self defense. It is not unusual for a member of a particular group to hold different views than others in that group. His view of the Palestinians being compared to the Jews in the Wassau ghetto is beyond contemptible.
Originally posted by sh76On this specific topic I surrender and withdraw.
1,000 deaths or thereabouts out of 1.8 million people is roughly 1/20 of one percent. The operation is in response to thousands of rockets launched at Israeli civilian areas.
The "Final Solution to the Jewish Question" resulted in the deaths of roughly 65% of European Jews. It was in response to no provocation at all.
I really can't believe I'm having to do this. :'(