By Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib (A Gazan-American activist for humanitarian assistance to Gaza) in the Free Press.
I have little to add. so, for those who don't subscribe to the FP:
The Most Disastrous Day in Palestinian History
Three years after October 7, Gaza lies devastated, Israeli attitudes have hardened, and the movement claiming to champion Palestinians still refuses to reckon with Hamas’s role in the catastrophe.
By Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib
As the grim third anniversary of October 7 befalls a decimated Gaza Strip, the state of the discourse among many in the so-called “pro-Palestine” movement remains as embarrassing, dismal, and disastrous as it was when Hamas initiated the attack in 2023. Over the past three years, I have seen countless posts by self-described Zionists criticizing the conduct of Israel’s government, the behavior of Israeli officials, and the excesses of the Israeli reaction to October 7. And yet, I have struggled to see even a dozen posts by “pro-Palestine” activists, advocates, or organizations explicitly condemning Hamas for triggering the most catastrophic chapter in contemporary Palestinian history.
And let’s be clear: That’s exactly what this is. Three years after October 7, the Palestinian people face their greatest crisis of the modern era.
I begin on the ground, in Gaza itself. The majority of Gaza’s buildings are partially or fully destroyed. Tens of thousands have lost their lives, including entire families wiped out by ferocious Israeli bombardment. People will argue to the moon and back about who was ultimately responsible for the level of devastation in Gaza. I personally believe Israel killed far too many civilians, including dozens of my own family members. Israeli air strikes destroyed both of my childhood homes. I will never not be angry or upset about this.
But I will also forever be furious at the fact that Gaza would still be standing had Hamas simply kept its terrorists at home on October 7. I will forever be rageful at the fact that Hamas not only weaponized every aspect of Gaza’s infrastructure but also held Israeli hostages in a manner that was inevitably going to invite more devastation and suffering for Palestinian civilians. I will forever be resentful of the useful idiots who ignored Hamas’s sadistic tactics, hiding behind vacuous appeals to “international law” despite there being no legal framework to justify a terrorist group entrenching itself in medical facilities, educational spaces, markets, and areas meant to shelter the displaced.
In initiating October 7, Hamas turned Gaza into the fulcrum for instability, devastation, and conflict in the Middle East. Palestinians’ Arab neighbors, including Lebanon, Iran, Yemen, Syria, Iraq, and Egypt, have long perceived them and their cause as a source of instability. This disastrous day only deepened that perception—perhaps irrevocably.
Worst of all, much of the Israeli public has been traumatized and lost to an uncompromising view of their Palestinian neighbors. Even those who once believed in peace are now increasingly suspicious of the prospect of coexistence with the Palestinians. Israeli attitudes have hardened, and the right wing emboldened. Few see a path forward that includes a Palestinian state.
In the West, the focus is on the “pro-Palestine” cause, which has manifested in protests raging in European capitals and on American college campuses, the recognition of a Palestinian state by multiple Western countries, and countless acts of “solidarity” across academia, journalism, and NGOs. And yet, there has been a universal failure to translate global sympathy into meaningful action.
Instead, the “pro-Palestine” industrial complex has hidden under misinformed slogans, pushed ugly sentiments, and fueled antisemitism across the world, all while Hamas continues to run rampant over Palestinians’ futures.
The West does not blame the terrorist group for the territory’s suffering; they blame Israel.
In other words, three years after the October 7 attacks on Israel, Palestinians have seen their homes decimated, their reputations destroyed in both Israel and the Arab world, and the actions of their supposed allies in the West amount to nothing. Yes, this has been the most catastrophic three years in modern Palestinian history.
This is not the first time that Palestinian leadership has taken a course of action that received no scrutiny or accountability, but instead inevitably caused harm, suffering, devastation, and setbacks to the Palestinian people. In 2000, Yasser Arafat launched the Second Intifada against Israel. That same year, he failed to present a viable counterproposal to the peace terms offered at Camp David. In 2008, Mahmoud Abbas rejected Ehud Olmert’s peace proposal; eight years later, he refused to work with Donald Trump in peace mediation. Each of these instances has been followed by a predictable cycle of international outrage and anger that removes any agency or accountability from Palestinian leaders or political factions.
Today, despite Gaza receiving more aid and development money per capita during the nearly two decades under Hamas’s rule than any other conflict zone in the world, the West does not blame the terrorist group for the territory’s suffering; they blame Israel. They ignore Hamas’s deliberate and willful choice to militarize Gaza’s society and infrastructure for perpetual warfare against Israel; they overlook multiple opportunities presented to Gaza to develop an airport, a seaport, and economic projects; and they continue to sacrifice a nation-building agenda in favor of perpetuating Hamas’s “resistance” narrative.
I have said repeatedly, despite facing skepticism from Jewish and Israeli audiences, that the majority of Gazans, for a variety of reasons, are indeed against Hamas, regardless of what faulty polls might suggest. That doesn’t mean they’re pro-Israel or envision peace with the Jewish state any time soon, especially after three years of a traumatic war and devastation. But it does mean they recognize that the terror group has wreaked unimaginable destruction on their lives, even if they hold grievances toward Israel.
The problem, of course, is that neither they nor their allies in the West will say so. Three years after October 7, the “pro-Palestine” movement cannot even bring itself to utter a simple condemnation of Hamas. Even the horrendous settlers who engage in terrorism against Palestinians in the West Bank are condemned by many Israelis, and by leaders within the settlement movement. So why can’t the “pro-Palestine” movement condemn Hamas? Separating Hamas from the Palestinian people is not some form of acquiescence to a hostile Western mindset; it is the height of serving Palestinian interests.
And it is the only viable path forward. Opportunities for a comprehensive resolution for the Palestinian people are highly unlikely in the near term. Suspicions of Israelis, terror sympathies, and anti-Western misinformation are highly entrenched in Gazan educational systems. An entire society is being raised to hate Israel, at the same time that Israel increasingly turns against Palestinians in the coastal enclave. But Gaza can be ground zero for making the case for Palestinian self-governance, statehood, and peaceful relations with Israel. After all, though Hamas remains an obstacle, it is a shell of itself. Israel already controls nearly 70 percent of Gaza’s territory, possibly allowing for opportunities to free the Gazan population from Hamas’s grip and deliver a knockout blow to this terror regime once and for all.
However, a narrative shift is of paramount importance. To promote a fundamentally different future for the Palestinian people in Gaza and beyond, we must acknowledge that within the massive power differential between Israel and the Palestinians, there exists an immense margin for Palestinian agency, responsibility, and accountability. Recognizing that is far from “blaming the victims,” as many of my detractors allege; it is, in fact, the first step toward empowering the Palestinian people.
1 edit
@sh76 saidThere were plenty of posts, articles, etc. condemning Hamas. The difference is that Israel, 3 years later, is *still* attacking civilians. Hamas is not.
Over the past three years, I have seen countless posts by self-described Zionists criticizing the conduct of Israel’s government, the behavior of Israeli officials, and the excesses of the Israeli reaction to October 7. And yet, I have struggled to see even a dozen posts by “pro-Palestine” activists, advocates, or organizations explicitly condemning Hamas for triggering the most catastrophic chapter in contemporary Palestinian history.
Hamas is evil and should be wiped off the face of the earth. Murder them all. Fine with me. But the continued killing of Palestinian civilians is inexcusable. Same for the violence against them in the West Bank or the continued stealing land.
I will give you this: there's FAR more criticism of Israel by liberals than of Hamas. Every time Hamas attacked with rockets, there was always an excuse by liberal crowds as to how this is Israel's fault; but retaliation by Israel is always met with disapproval.
That's not fair.
But the pro-Israel crowd refuses to acknowledge any of Israel's wrongs, like in the West Bank. In fact, they often justify these actions and paint Palestinians as savage animals who deserve to have land stolen.
They also fail to draw a distinction between a terrorist group and the Palestinians themselves. This is like blaming Russian citizens for Putin.
Both sides of this debate are goddamn retards.
@sh76 saidWrong. The most disastrous day in the history of the Arabs in Palestine, is 14th May 1948. That was the day the made the fatal decision to take on the Jews, and stop them from setting up a Jewish state.
By Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib (A Gazan-American activist for humanitarian assistance to Gaza) in the Free Press.
I have little to add. so, for those who don't subscribe to the FP:The Most Disastrous Day in Palestinian History
Three years after October 7, Gaza lies devastated, Israeli attitudes have hardened, and the movement claiming to champion Palestinians still re ...[text shortened]... detractors allege; it is, in fact, the first step toward empowering the Palestinian people.
@vivify saidHamas has not surrendered. So the war continues and civilians will die, as civilians are put at risk deliberately so that Hamas soldiers can be protected.
Hamas is evil and should be wiped off the face of the earth. Murder them all. Fine with me. But the continued killing of Palestinian civilians is inexcusable. Same for the violence against them in the West Bank or the continued stealing land.
Maybe this will explain the difference to you :
- In Israel [as in many civilized nations, the civilians/people are put in shelters and protected during times of conflict and war.
- Among Muslims, the soldiers are protected in tunnels and shelters and the civilians are put in the firing line.
Because Hamas has not surrendered, the IDF still has the task of rooting them out and destroying the military facilities. Civilians will die.
@Rajk999 saidMakes sense.
Hamas has not surrendered. So the war continues and civilians will die, as civilians are put at risk deliberately so that Hamas soldiers can be protected.
Maybe this will explain the difference to you :
- In Israel [as in many civilized nations, the civilians/people are put in shelters and protected during times of conflict and war.
- Among Muslims, the soldiers are p ...[text shortened]... still has the task of rooting them out and destroying the military facilities. Civilians will die.
But posters like yourself don't claim it's a necessary evil where civilian deaths are unavoidable; they often claim Palestinians deserve death. That what crosses you over into being wrong and being just like Hamas.
In the West Bank where there are no excuses for Israeli annexation, pro-Israel crowds either shrug or defend it.
@vivify saidThe West Bank issue was discussed in another thread. In a nutshell the Palestinian Authority, Arafat was there at the time, agreed to a division of West Bank so that suicide bombers could be controlled. Area C which is under full control of Israel and where there are tight security and border checks, is where all the trouble takes place because Palestinians violate these security measures.
Makes sense.
But posters like yourself don't claim it's a necessary evil where civilian deaths are unavoidable; they often claim Palestinians deserve death. That what crosses you over into being wrong and being just like Hamas.
In the West Bank where there are no excuses for Israeli annexation, pro-Israel crowds either shrug or defend it.
My take on the so-called innocence of the Palestinians is the issue in the opening post. They do not condemn Hamas. They in fact support Hamas and agree to hide soldiers, weapons and other military stuff in their homes. This makes them complicit and guilty, and worse it changes their status from civilian to military. According to the Geneva Convention, these supporters of the military are justifiable targets.
@Rajk999 saidWhat utter BS. Oslo's division of the West Bank was never meant to be permanent; the Accords themselves called for a final status agreement within 5 years. The Israeli right wing repudiated the Accords even making a hero of the extremist who murdered the Prime Minister who signed it. Then Israel poured settlers into the West Bank to make sure the two State solution Oslo envisioned would never happen.
The West Bank issue was discussed in another thread. In a nutshell the Palestinian Authority, Arafat was there at the time, agreed to a division of West Bank so that suicide bombers could be controlled. Area C which is under full control of Israel and where there are tight security and border checks, is where all the trouble takes place because Palestinians violate these s ...[text shortened]... tary. According to the Geneva Convention, these supporters of the military are justifiable targets.
You know virtually nothing of the real history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and your posts are filled with hateful and malicious disinformation.
And no, civilian supporters are not legitimate military targets according to any international agreements; you are making, again, the exact same argument that Osama Bin Laden did.
@Rajk999 saidhttps://www.un.org/unispal/document/auto-insert-185434/
The West Bank issue was discussed in another thread. In a nutshell the Palestinian Authority, Arafat was there at the time, agreed to a division of West Bank so that suicide bombers could be controlled. Area C which is under full control of Israel and where there are tight security and border checks, is where all the trouble takes place because Palestinians violate these security measures.
That was an interim agreement meant to last only 5 years, back in 1995.
My take on the so-called innocence of the Palestinians is the issue in the opening post. They do not condemn Hamas. They in fact support Hamas and agree to hide soldiers, weapons and other military stuff in their homes. This makes them complicit and guilty, and worse it changes their status from civilian to military. According to the Geneva Convention, these supporters of the military are justifiable targets.
Israel bombed children schools. If your argument is that children and nurses were complicit in "military stuff", that proves my point. By starting your sentence with "so-called innocent", you dismiss the possibility you may wrong to justify their killing.
Keep in mind Hamas is a terrorist group that has used oppression and torture against their own people in order to keep them in line:
https://www.hrw.org/report/2018/10/23/two-authorities-one-way-zero-dissent/arbitrary-arrest-and-torture-under
This is like blaming North Koreans for complying with their military.
@no1marauder saidYeah .. it was supposed to end after 5 years, but the West Bank Palestinians carried on with even more suicide bombing after the Oslo Accords. So they screwed themselves.
What utter BS. Oslo's division of the West Bank was never meant to be permanent; the Accords themselves called for a final status agreement within 5 years. The Israeli right wing repudiated the Accords even making a hero of the extremist who murdered the Prime Minister who signed it. Then Israel poured settlers into the West Bank to make sure the two State solution Oslo e ...[text shortened]... y international agreements; you are making, again, the exact same argument that Osama Bin Laden did.
Did suicide bombing of Jewish targets increase from 1990 to 2005 ?
Lets hear you answer that.
According to the Geneva Convention using your home or property as a military storage and you are supplying soldiers with hardware etc, then your home is a justifiable target, and can be bombed.
Lots of that in Gaza.
@vivify saidThats their problem. In any case nobody buying that, when they are dancing and celebrating when they see dead Jews, and they are draging the naked bodies of women in the streets and praising Allah. They are all complicit.
Keep in mind Hamas is a terrorist group that has used oppression and torture against their own people in order to keep them in line:
As for the 5 year olds .. its the parents who put them in harms way.
@vivify saidVenezuelans elected a socialist Chavez in 1999 and they suffered badly for it. Its their problem, and I dont care if they have to suffer. Its a fact of life that people have to pay for their bad decisions.
Point proven. Your statements are not motivated by logic but by hate.
Same with Gazans. They elected Hamas and support them.