2 edits
@Rajk999 saidI've done so many times and you have ignored me every time.
Can you respond in a positive manner. It helps along the discussion. Rather than say what it is not, say what, where it is. Thanks.
Palestine is the southeastern Mediterranean coast from Egypt north to beyond Ashdod. It is west of Judah (AKA the West Bank of the River Jordan) and southwest of Israel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philistia#/media/File:Kingdoms_around_Israel_830_map.svg
(map is approximate)
I look forward to the next time we have this exact same conversation because you never absorbed what I said this time.
@Rajk999 saidAre you still refusing to answer my question and hiding behind AI?
You are equating what Egypt did here :
Egypt: Citizenship laws restricted nationality in ways that left many Jews (along with Greeks, Italians and other minorities) effectively stateless, since Egyptian nationality law required Arabic as a mother tongue. This became the pretext for mass expulsions, especially of Jews holding French or British passports. After the 1956 S ...[text shortened]... 00 by 1957, and only a few hundred by 1970.
with the US or ICE expelling illegal immigrants?
@AThousandYoung saidOk .. so what are you saying? Is it that Israel has no place in that Levant region?
I've done so many times and you have ignored me every time.
Palestine is the southeastern Mediterranean coast from Egypt north to beyond Ashdod. It is west of Judah (AKA the West Bank of the River Jordan) and southwest of Israel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philistia
I look forward to the next time we have this exact same conversation because you never absorbed what I said this time.
Most of modern Israel currently comprises Judah and Israel on your map.
@AThousandYoung saidRephrase the question stating exactly what the US is doing. I read what Claude said Egypt did. They rrequired Arab language as a requirement. Is the US doing that?
Are you still refusing to answer my question and hiding behind AI?
2 edits
@Rajk999 saidYou still aren't answering my question.
Rephrase the question stating exactly what the US is doing. I read what Claude said Egypt did. They rrequired Arab language as a requirement. Is the US doing that?
Should countries be able to deport foreigners who won't assimilate, refuse to use the official national language and are acting as foreign agents?
Many of those Jews were persecuted for being active Zionist agents...according to YOUR quoted post.
Own what you write. Stop the passive aggressive posting AI and then pretending you had nothing to do with the message.
@vivify saidThe info from Claude summarised the events after the 1948 war. I cannot say how long the expulsion went on for. Care to check and let us know? Or are you here just to disagree instead of learning the truth.
The most recent instance of Jewish expulsion given in your post is from the 1950's.
By your post, this means that Jewish ethnic cleansing has long been over; correct?
@Rajk999 saidI didn't disagree with anything. Calm down.
The info from Claude summarised the events after the 1948 war. I cannot say how long the expulsion went on for. Care to check and let us know? Or are you here just to disagree instead of learning the truth.
I merely asked you if we can agree that significant instances of Jewish ethnic cleanses are no longer an issue. Do you agree?
1 edit
https://www.cnn.com/2026/07/20/middleeast/israel-far-right-settlements-gaza-intl
With elections looming in October, Israel’s right wing is turning the push to rebuild Jewish settlements in Gaza into a central issue of their campaign.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/02/israel-seeking-trumps-support-for-plan-to-expel-palestinians-from-gaza
Israel ‘seeking Trump’s support for plan to expel Palestinians from Gaza’
@AThousandYoung saidThe expression 'refusing to assimilate' is vague. I asked already what do you mean by that in the context of the US situation.
You still aren't answering my question.
Should countries be able to deport foreigners who won't assimilate, refuse to use the official national language and are acting as foreign agents?
Many of those Jews were persecuted for being active Zionist agents...according to YOUR quoted post.
Own what you write. Stop the passive aggressive posting AI and then pretending you had nothing to do with the message.
In Egypt the govt required Arab language in order to be a citizen or something like that.
This is not the case in the US.
I cannot answer your vague question.
@Rajk999 saidThe word "US" is not present anywhere in my question.
The expression 'refusing to assimilate' is vague. I asked already what do you mean by that in the context of the US situation.
In Egypt the govt required Arab language in order to be a citizen or something like that.
This is not the case in the US.
I cannot answer your vague question.
https://archive-yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/calls-mount-everywhere-deportation-illegal-immigrants
Fueling calls for increased deportations are frustrations and disappointments with multiculturalism and assimilation, contributing to anti-immigrant sentiments. Various national leaders and party officials – most recently in Germany, the Netherlands, Sweden and Switzerland – have expressed serious doubts about the success of immigrant integration, especially among those who differ religiously and ethnically from their host communities.
https://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-immigrant-assimilation-2017-story.html
Trump wants immigrants to ‘share our values.’ They say assimilation is much more complex
“Not everyone who seeks to join our country will be able to successfully assimilate,” President Trump said in a campaign-trail speech in which he called for new immigrants to pass an “ideological certification to make sure that those we are admitting to our country share our values and love our people.”
@AThousandYoung saidYou said ...Muslims and Hispanics are being hunted down and expelled or killed by the government in the USA for refusing to assimilate and speak English and you are cheering them on every step of the way.
The word "US" is not present anywhere in my question.
Yes, Im cheering to expel Muslims. I have stated the reasons dozens of times.
I am not cheering to expel Hispanics, unless they are wailfully illegal and/or criminal.
In these cases I support expelling immigrants. I do not, and have never supported a blanket expulsion of immigrants.