Thousand wrote that to me. Unbelievable
Here is a primer to Thousand, and to the disgruntled..
Capitalism doesn’t require you to be rich to participate in it. It gives you the freedom to earn a wage, negotiate a better one, own a business, invest, or compete. The irony is that you’re criticizing a system for allowing people to profit from their work (🤔)while defending an ideology that has repeatedly concentrated economic power in the hands of the state. The problem isn’t profit. It’s exploitation. Follow me. guvung government more power doesn’t make exploitation disappear.
And just because a guy profits (gets rich in your mind) profit itself isn’t proof of exploitation. The real test is whether people have meaningful choices, fair competition, and the freedom to improve their circumstances. Is not everyone free to make their own way in the United States of America?. If you are going to be so critical, tell us what entity or occasion holds someone back.
@AverageJoe1 saidYou’re babbling. I never said any of that.
Thousand wrote that to me. Unbelievable
Here is a primer to Thousand, and to the disgruntled..
Capitalism doesn’t require you to be rich to participate in it. It gives you the freedom to earn a wage, negotiate a better one, own a business, invest, or compete. The irony is that you’re criticizing a system for allowing people to profit from their work (🤔)while ...[text shortened]... of America?. If you are going to be so critical, tell us what entity or occasion holds someone back.
ATYDS
@AThousandYoung saidYou do not want to mess with AvJoe . Then perhaps you should clarify what you meant, because your own words were that ‘capitalism exists so that rich people can profit from the labor of workers’. You did not say that capitalism ‘can allow’ rich people to profit from workers orthat some employers exploited their workers. You said that this is what capitalism EXISTS FOR. Geez. I have done this banter for 50 years. You would fail English 101.
You’re babbling. I never said any of that.
ATYDS
The Forum, a ship of fools!!
A teaching moment. All you did was describe the purpose of capitalism, not merely oneoutcome. I didn’t put those words in your mouth. The conclusion is obvious from what you said. Never make a sweeping complaint about capitalism or any subject and then disowned the application when someone challenges you on it.
@AverageJoe1 saidHypocrite!
You do not want to mess with AvJoe . Then perhaps you should clarify what you meant, because your own words were that ‘capitalism exists so that rich people can profit from the labor of workers’. You did not say that capitalism ‘can allow’ rich people to profit from workers orthat some employers exploited their workers. You said that this is what capitalism EXISTS FOR. Ge ...[text shortened]... about capitalism or any subject and then disowned the application when someone challenges you on it.
@AverageJoe1 saidHe's right.
Thousand wrote that to me. Unbelievable
Here is a primer to Thousand, and to the disgruntled..
Capitalism doesn’t require you to be rich to participate in it. It gives you the freedom to earn a wage, negotiate a better one, own a business, invest, or compete. The irony is that you’re criticizing a system for allowing people to profit from their work (🤔)while ...[text shortened]... of America?. If you are going to be so critical, tell us what entity or occasion holds someone back.
The problem is augmented when normal Americans think they'll be rich one day if they only support the rich.
But go ahead, gaslighter, you do you.
@Suzianne saidYou should write Thousand , not me. My post lacks nothing, it is a perfect analysis, beginning with his saying what capitalism exist for, which is a totally incorrect statement. I challenge you to Google “What does capitalism exist for’ , and send us any answer at all, which comes even close to what he said.. geez Sue. TDS is quite pervasive.
Hypocrite!
This that I suggest to you in itself will prove me correct.
Or, take a shot at proving hypocrisy on my part
@AverageJoe1
As with many of your comments on this forum you seem to have an 'idealized' view of how the economy works. I've tried many times to highlight this - so why not one more?
Last year witnessed a record number of mergers and acquisitions - totaling roughly $4.5 trillion - theses actions generate a great deal of wealth but rarely (if ever) actually create any economic growth/ jobs etc. in the 'real' economy as they often involve redundancies.
In your (idealized) world butchers, bakers and candlestick makers (an English phrase) are all busy creating wealth but - in reality - they have all been bought up by hedge funds, replaced by robots and 'rationalized.'
That you are deluded about how wealth is created is also evidenced by your hyping of the Dow Jones etc. which is (unfortunately) a HUGE bubble and is not at all indicative of real economic activity - hence despite record levels in the Dow most US citizens feel less well off and are extremely concerned with the economy...
@AverageJoe1 saidCapitalism exists as a much better economic system compared to feudalism, but also not without faults or without need of reform when necessary. People put up capitalism as some infallible truth it is not that.
No, no no no no, he is not right. He is wrong. That is not what capitalism exists for.
Geez
Right now there's extreme wealth consolidation in our economic system which has skewed incentives against generating new things. A single billionaire can "donate" hundreds of millions of dollars to specific politicians with the expectations that they will keep the taxation low on their own earnings and taxation high on everyone elses. The solution has to be some kind of return to progressive taxation or wealth taxes so the people who work for a living can still make ends meet.
@beardmusic saidWith all due respect, you have a lot more time on your hands than I do. I can’t imagine, tackling all of what you say. But one thing that jumps out at me, the example of butchers, bakers, and candlestickmakers actually makes my point about competition. You see, If hedge funds buy up local businesses, eliminate competitors, and leave consumers with fewer choices, that is a serious problem. So I do not treat your vommment lightly nor avoid it as the lesser posters do,
@AverageJoe1
As with many of your comments on this forum you seem to have an 'idealized' view of how the economy works. I've tried many times to highlight this - so why not one more?
Last year witnessed a record number of mergers and acquisitions - totaling roughly $4.5 trillion - theses actions generate a great deal of wealth but rarely (if ever) actually create any e ...[text shortened]... evels in the Dow most US citizens feel less well off and are extremely concerned with the economy...
But you’re “ saying that’ is not evidence that voluntary exchange, private ownership, and competition are inherently flawed. It may be evidence that competition is being undermined by consolidation. But you are a bit overboard to say that it is flawed. So this is an example of all of your writings that just throw things out there without basis.
And not to make light of your subject, but it would be better just to bring up one point to debateabout. Your comment is like one of Sunhouse Post..
Here’s question I’d like you to answer: If the problem is that powerful corporations are buying up competitors and reducing competition, why is yourconclusion that capitalism itself is the problem, rather than that we need stronger competition and antitrust enforcement?
I’m not defending every action taken by every corporation. This is a great economic system which I defend, where success is not supposed to depend on political connections or government favoritism.
You can corporate abuses is reasonable. But Treating those abuses as the whole story of capitalism is not.
It is funny that none of you will ever tell us how to or why or with what to replace capitalism. Why don’t you just get out there and work, and see what happens
Tell me, is any one person entitled to the labor of another?
It is very telling that I asked many questions that you people cannot or will not answer. It is my question of the century..
@AverageJoe1
Fair enough.
To attempt an answer, I'm certainly not saying that capitalism should be 'disregarded,' only that it does need to be 'balanced' by other elements - namely the government. As Marx (don't hyperventilate 😁) pointed out well over 100 years ago, capital (left to its own devices) will 'naturally" form into larger and larger conglomerates (ironically) to avoid the very real dangers that unfettered capitalism leads to. I don't claim that this is an 'iron rule' or 'law' simply a tendency that needs to be countered by the only other institution that we have that is strong enough to do this - the government. Basically I see it as a balancing act.
I hope that answers your question...
@beardmusic saidButim I’m not arguing for unfettered capitalism. I’m arguing for a system in which government protects fair competition without becoming so powerful, or so closely aligned with corporate interests that it undermines the very competition it’s supposed to protect.
@AverageJoe1
Fair enough.
To attempt an answer, I'm certainly not saying that capitalism should be 'disregarded,' only that it does need to be 'balanced' by other elements - namely the government. As Marx (don't hyperventilate 😁) pointed out well over 100 years ago, capital (left to its own devices) will 'naturally" form into larger and larger conglomerates (ironically) ...[text shortened]... his - the government. Basically I see it as a balancing act.
I hope that answers your question...
You call it a balancing act. I agree. But who balances the government when it gets too close to the corporations it is supposed to regulate? And how do we prevent government intervention from protecting established businesses at the expense of workers, consumers, and new competitors?
That, to me, is the real debate…. not whether government should have a role, but where its role should begin and end. You more than I are cool with govt. Uour man Mamdani said “seize th means of production!!”” Oh, you don’t agree with his philosophy?!!? Funny you’ve never said so. Going to say it now, are you? Curious
My suggestion: don’t try to score points by dismissing Marx or denying the risks of concentrated corporate power. Your friend has now
We both acknowledge that capitalism has a role, and I can acknowledge that government has a role too. Our disagreement is about how to constrain both corporate power and government power. That puts the conversation on the specific policies and evidence, rather than on idealogical labels.
We , you see are, realists
we for instance, do not think anyone is entitled to the labor of another. Do you think that anyone is entitled to the labor of another?
Beat Suzianne to the answer of that one.
@AverageJoe1
I agree with much that you have said but I fear that post-Reagan things have tilted too far towards unchecked corporate power via deregulation etc.
The whole point of Freidman and Hayek was that markets needed to provide a check on excessive government meddling (they had in mind the communist system of Russia at the time). Now in totally different circumstances globalization, communication technology etc. things have gone way too far the other way. The government (irrespective of who controls it) is basically for sale and has simply been absorbed by corporate and financial power...
@beardmusic saidI guess we are besting around the same bush . of course neither of us want cotps or government imbalance. And your statement that government has been ‘absorbed by corporate and financial power’ raises an important question: if government is already vulnerable to corporate capture, why assume that giving it more authority will necessarily solve the problem? The very corporations you want to restrain may be the ones best positioned to influence how that authority is used.
@AverageJoe1
I agree with much that you have said but I fear that post-Reagan things have tilted too far towards unchecked corporate power via deregulation etc.
The whole point of Freidman and Hayek was that markets needed to provide a check on excessive government meddling (they had in mind the communist system of Russia at the time). Now in totally different circumst ...[text shortened]... controls it) is basically for sale and has simply been absorbed by corporate and financial power...
Up to now, I have always thought that liberals want more government involved in our lives. Spread wealth, run our lives, create dependents,… certainly as evidence dby Schumer et al TODAY wanting all of the immigrants to come here and be made citizens. You and I would have to pay for that. We owe them nothing. Absolutely nothing.So now I seem to think that you’re posting once the government to back off. So you are a conservative.?? I’m not changing the subject, I am saying that y’all talk about this, but you never talk about the other problems that government is creating like opening our borders. You can start your crusade by opening pipelines and closing borders , if you get my drift, you people are really letting our country get away from us..
Well? Is one person entitled to the labor of another?? Say No and defeat all of you liberal govt mantras .
Would be interesting. It is not interesting for us to discuss economic theory. I noticed we have lost Susie. Downer.
Why don’t you cut to the Chase and discuss socialism or capitalism??????
@AverageJoe1 saidNah, your thesis is inaccurate. Larger government is not the solution that most people are asking for.
I guess we are besting around the same bush . of course neither of us want cotps or government imbalance. And your statement that government has been ‘absorbed by corporate and financial power’ raises an important question: if government is already vulnerable to corporate capture, why assume that giving it more authority will necessarily solve the problem? The very corpo ...[text shortened]... ve lost Susie. Downer.
Why don’t you cut to the Chase and discuss socialism or capitalism??????
The corporate and financial powers acting on government are specifically good at preventing government from taxing or regulating their specific industries, and they are specifically good at lobbying for loopholes and subsidies and contracts that support their personal wealth accumulation. They are good at this because they bribe politicians with campaign contributions.
Elon Musk is an extreme example of this, where he actually worked in government and fired the exact people whose job it was to provide oversight to his own companies. And now he's given hundreds of millions of dollars to elect people who will calcify the regulatory code that allow him to succeed at the expense of others.