Go back
Trouble afoot in the oil refineries

Trouble afoot in the oil refineries

Debates


@wildgrass said
I dunno about price fixing..but the cost of gas doubled and the corporate profit doubled in a very short time frame. Our government blames the war in Iran. It seems like a convenient excuse.

We at least deserve coherent explanations for how that can happen.
The cost of gas doubled and the corporate profit doubled in a very short time and you want to blame investors? You are talking about refinery profits, not investor profits.

That can only be explained by price fixing. They know people will assume it is because of the price of oil. That is only part of it. When refinery profits double it is not because of the price of oil. And it is not because of oil speculators. They do not control refinery profits.


@Metal-Brain said
Raised prices? How?

Price fixing requires reducing supply to raise prices. That is how I explain the price rise. They shut down refineries and are not building any new refineries. It is well known there is a refinery shortage. If they were competitive some company would build a new one or restore one that was shut down. Since that is not happening they must be price fixing which is a monopoly and illegal. There I explained it in detail.

How do you explain yours?
They raise prices by charging more for refined gasoline.


@wildgrass said
They raise prices by charging more for refined gasoline.
That is not possible without restricting supply. You need to explain how that can happen in a competitive market. Or you could just admit it is NOT a competitive market and I was right all along.

Remember during the pandemic gasoline was briefly pennies per gallon? That was because of a lack of demand because nobody was driving much. People are driving less because of the high prices and the price is not coming down. That is because of a lack of supply. Not oil, refined fuel.

The price of oil really is not that high. The price of oil is not the main reason fuel prices are high. The refiners are restricting supply. That is a symptom of price fixing. Competitors do not restrict supply. They supply the demand to make money....unless they are not competitors.

I propose government build refineries to compete with these so called harmless competitors. After all, the profits are there. Right? How could the US taxpayer lose? If these so called competitors will not build new refineries or fix up old abandoned ones then why not have government build some?

Better yet, write Trump and ask him to invest all that money he got from cryptocurrency trading and use it to build a refinery. He knows there is a shortage of refineries. He also knows there is a lot of potential profit to be made if he did.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@wildgrass said
Wall Street is abuzz with this story about how oil refineries are printing their own money these days. Since the USA randomly decided to start bombing Iran, US oil refineries have seen their profits more than double or even triple or more in the last months. Profits. Marathon refining goes from $200 million in quarterly profit to $6 billion in quarterly profit since the war ...[text shortened]... m/business/2026/oct/07/shell-refineries-forecast-to-make-double-the-profit-from-every-barrel-of-fuel
It feels just like capitalism. Capitalists love monopolies. John D. Rockefeller said competition was sin. Carnegie sold his steel monopoly to J.P. Morgan. Monopolies are what capitalists strive for.