Go back
Worst year to be alive

Worst year to be alive

Debates


The volcanic winter of 536.

https://history.fas.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum4421/files/gibbons_a_2018_science_mag_re_ad536.pdf

That volcano caused global cooling. Some refer to it as the mini ice age or little ice age. We are finally coming out of that cooling of the climate. That is why the climate is warming. It is natural and completely normal for that to happen.

There is a reason people like Al Gore lied to us about it. They want to scare people into accepting a carbon tax that will raise your fuel prices. Now that fuel prices are higher because of the Iran war and refineries price fixing the democrats are complaining about the very thing they wanted. High fuel prices.

It is time for people to demand we burn less fossil fuels by efficiency improvements. Not to save the planet, but to conserve finite fossil fuels.
It is time to admit we all hate high fuel prices. And to admit a carbon tax would just be used to fund endless wars that increase carbon emissions.

Inform all of your family and friends about the volcanic wither of 536.
Most people do not know about it. Now that fuel prices are bothering everyone now is the time to talk about it. The idea of a carbon tax needs to be killed. Nobody wants that kind of solution. Especially since it is not a real solution.


The article mentions absolutely nothing about how earth is "coming out of that cooling of the climate of 536".

If you believe what the scientists in this article are saying, why don't you contact them to ask whether the earth is coming out of that cooling phase? And if they - in a friendly manner - tell you you're full of it, will you still believe their science, or will you then question their honesty?

It is true that a carbon tax is not the solution. It is merely a means to a solution, which is a drastic reduction of fossil fuel usage.


@Great-King-Rat

I did not make up the little ice age.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age

Are you claiming that the horrific volcanic winter of 536 could not trigger global cooling? Because that could have caused ocean currents to change. Another possible explanation is a dimming of solar activity of the sun. But that is heresy to global warming alarmists. They tell me that is impossible. They refuse to accept that.


@Metal-Brain said
@Great-King-Rat

I did not make up the little ice age.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age

Are you claiming that the horrific volcanic winter of 536 could not trigger global cooling? Because that could have caused ocean currents to change. Another possible explanation is a dimming of solar activity of the sun. But that is heresy to global warming alarmists. They tell me that is impossible. They refuse to accept that.
Are you going to offer scientific evidence showing that earth is currently warming up from the cold of 536, or are you only using science when it suits you?


@Great-King-Rat
"It is true that a carbon tax is not the solution. It is merely a means to a solution, which is a drastic reduction of fossil fuel usage."

Since Trump waged an unprovoked war on Iran how much has fossil fuel usage been reduced? Not that Zelensky bombing oil refineries in Russia does not increase carbon emissions, but let's stick with fossil fuel usage for now and assume Zelensky will stop it soon.


@Great-King-Rat said
Are you going to offer scientific evidence showing that earth is currently warming up from the cold of 536, or are you only using science when it suits you?
Answer my question first. Evading questions and expecting answers to your questions is a poor debating tactic with me.

Are you claiming that the horrific volcanic winter of 536 could not trigger global cooling? Because that could have caused ocean currents to change.


@Great-King-Rat said
Are you going to offer scientific evidence showing that earth is currently warming up from the cold of 536, or are you only using science when it suits you?
It was not only 536. There was a series of volcanic eruptions following that, 536 was clearly the worst of them.

https://everything.explained.today/Volcanic_winter_of_536/


@Metal-Brain said
The volcanic winter of 536.

https://history.fas.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum4421/files/gibbons_a_2018_science_mag_re_ad536.pdf

That volcano caused global cooling. Some refer to it as the mini ice age or little ice age. We are finally coming out of that cooling of the climate. That is why the climate is warming. It is natural and completely normal for that to hap ...[text shortened]... needs to be killed. Nobody wants that kind of solution. Especially since it is not a real solution.
So you can find a curve for the global temperature here:

https://phys.org/news/2019-07-20th-century-unmatched-years.html

Now your argument again?


@Ponderable said
So you can find a curve for the global temperature here:

https://phys.org/news/2019-07-20th-century-unmatched-years.html

Now your argument again?
Many studies of temperature rely on the heat island effect which is not representative of global warming. It is a representation of urban temperatures.

If I am wrong you can easily prove it with sea level rise. When glaciers melt we all know where it goes, the ocean. Prove it with sea level rise.


@Metal-Brain said
Many studies of temperature rely on the heat island effect which is not representative of global warming. It is a representation of urban temperatures.

If I am wrong you can easily prove it with sea level rise. When glaciers melt we all know where it goes, the ocean. Prove it with sea level rise.
So what is sea level measurement the past few decades?

doi:10.59327/IPCC/AR6-9789291691647

gives: 1901-1970 1,3 mm/year
1971-2006 1,9 mm/year
2006-2018 3,7 mm/ year

all added together sea level rose in the past 120 years by about one foot.

So do we see an increase?


@Metal-Brain said
Answer my question first. Evading questions and expecting answers to your questions is a poor debating tactic with me.

Are you claiming that the horrific volcanic winter of 536 could not trigger global cooling? Because that could have caused ocean currents to change.
I asked you a question first.

You can check this by looking for the "?" sign.


@Ponderable said
So what is sea level measurement the past few decades?

doi:10.59327/IPCC/AR6-9789291691647

gives: 1901-1970 1,3 mm/year
1971-2006 1,9 mm/year
2006-2018 3,7 mm/ year

all added together sea level rose in the past 120 years by about one foot.

So do we see an increase?
The past few decades is irrelevant. Sea level rise goes back for more than 120 years. Show me graph of that entire time period. No omissions or cherry picking data. Cherry picking data is why you think temps are rising at an alarming rate.

Of course there is an increase in sea level. We both agree there is global warming. We only disagree with the cause of it. Over 120 years ago there was less CO2 in the atmosphere than now. Show me a graph over that time period and identify the alarming rise in sea level that correlates with CO2 rise in the atmosphere over that time period.

And don't try to digress into something else. This is about sea level rise.proving temp data is not cherry picked. Nothing else.


@Great-King-Rat

Let me help you out. Here is a graph going back over 140 years.

https://globalocean.noaa.gov/the-ocean/sea-level/

Show me where the alarming acceleration of sea level rise is.


@Metal-Brain said
@Great-King-Rat

Let me help you out. Here is a graph going back over 140 years.

https://globalocean.noaa.gov/the-ocean/sea-level/

Show me where the alarming acceleration of sea level rise is.
If you’re already struggling to keep track of who you’re talking to in your own thread, should you really bother yourself with complicated science?


@Ponderable
Let me help you out. Here is a graph going back over 140 years.

https://globalocean.noaa.gov/the-ocean/sea-level/

Show me where the alarming acceleration of sea level rise is.