Go back
Illegal Move occurred in my game??

Illegal Move occurred in my game??

General

Vote Up
Vote Down

Do i misunderstand the rules of chess, or has the site allowed an illegal move here? My bishop is covering one of the squares that the king has just castled over...

I thought you couyldn't castle over a square that wa under attack??

Game 3789511

Cheers,

M

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Do i misunderstand the rules of chess, or has the site allowed an illegal move here? My bishop is covering one of the squares that the king has just castled over...

I thought you couyldn't castle over a square that wa under attack??

Game 3789511

Cheers,

M
The king has to pass through a check for it to be illegal. Only the rook passes through your bishop's line.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Do i misunderstand the rules of chess, or has the site allowed an illegal move here? My bishop is covering one of the squares that the king has just castled over...

I thought you couyldn't castle over a square that wa under attack??

Game 3789511

Cheers,

M
your bishop was covering the b8 square, he castled queenside, so there are no illegal moves that have been played.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Do i misunderstand the rules of chess, or has the site allowed an illegal move here? My bishop is covering one of the squares that the king has just castled over...

I thought you couyldn't castle over a square that wa under attack??

Game 3789511

Cheers,

M
No it's not.

Your bishop is not covering where the king is castling. The rook can pass over a white-protected square. the king cannot.

You mistake yourself.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Do i misunderstand the rules of chess, or has the site allowed an illegal move here? My bishop is covering one of the squares that the king has just castled over...

I thought you couyldn't castle over a square that wa under attack??

Game 3789511

Cheers,

M
The king was not under attack, that is what matters, the rook is not important.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shortcircuit
The king has to pass through a check for it to be illegal. Only the rook passes through your bishop's line.
Ahha!

Then I DO misunderstand - after all these years... *laughs at self* 🙄

M

Vote Up
Vote Down

You guys are sooooo slow responding. 😛

Vote Up
Vote Down

Its the quickest responses i've EVER had to a post - thanks all! 🙂

M

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Its the quickest responses i've EVER had to a post - thanks all! 🙂

M
We are the quicker fixer-uppers

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Ahha!

Then I DO misunderstand - after all these years... *laughs at self* 🙄

M
Don't feel bad, Victor Korchnoi asked that same question in one of his Candidates games against Karpov. (or was it one of the Championship match games)
If a GM can ask, why can't you?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Ahha!

Then I DO misunderstand - after all these years... *laughs at self* 🙄

M
Don't feel too bad. You're in good company. Korchnoi had to ask an arbiter essentially the same question about the castling rule during the final Candidates match for the World Championship!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Korchnoi


EDIT: too slow.... 😞 It's an interesting read.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by shortcircuit
You guys are sooooo slow responding. 😛
Well pardon us. We'll try and be a bit quicker on the draw next time.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by noxidjkram
Do i misunderstand the rules of chess, or has the site allowed an illegal move here? My bishop is covering one of the squares that the king has just castled over...

I thought you couyldn't castle over a square that wa under attack??

Game 3789511

Cheers,

M
Lord kill me now please. 😞

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ice Cold
Lord kill me now please. 😞
bang, bang

Vote Up
Vote Down