RHP Prose Competition 2020 - stories and voting thread

RHP Prose Competition 2020 - stories and voting thread

General

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.

chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
656282
17 May 20

So here are the results, I invite everybody to double-check and I will fire up the second round Voting thread in the eraly afternoon.

Results:

1 Release 28
2 Dogma 23
3 A reason to live 22
4 This little piggy 21
----------------------------
5 In which Reginald goes for a walk 20
6 Billy Southgate 11
7 Lockdown 10
8 Beyond the Horizon 8
Soulsearching 8
10 Victoria's Wedding 6
11 Mr. Wilson's board Meeting 2
Rose coloured glasses 2
13 Escape 1
14 LUCKY ME!
Cynthia

As it Looks now it would have been nice if the Reginald Story would have made the cut, but alas, the rules were fixed before.

Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined
09 Jun 07
Moves
48793
17 May 20

@wolfe63 said
This year there are at least 5 solid selections that deserve to be #1. Displayed here is a high caliber of creativity. The effort that it takes to write originally cannot be under-rated. Thus it's difficult to make hair-splitting choices. But make them we must:

1pt. - "Mr. Wilson's Board Meeting"
3pts.- "Lockdown"
5pts.- "This Little Piggy"
I too thought there were 5 clearly superior entries.
But I had only one of your top 3 in there!

All a matter of taste and they were all clearly very good.

chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
656282
17 May 20

I will post comments on the stories after the curtain fell, and I want to encourage you to do the same.

Eight stories got a first place vote at least once, which shows the quality of the competition.

The Ghost Chamber

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
28736
17 May 20

@ponderable said
I will post comments on the stories after the curtain fell, and I want to encourage you to do the same.

Eight stories got a first place vote at least once, which shows the quality of the competition.
Having the final round is an interesting twist this year. Hope it goes swimmingly.

😀

Joined
06 Nov 15
Moves
41301
17 May 20
1 edit

@wolfgang59 said
I too thought there were 5 clearly superior entries.
But I had only one of your top 3 in there!

All a matter of taste and they were all clearly very good.
Did you even vote?

Anyway, criteria dependent decisions were not easily made.

One man's candy,
can taste sweeter than...
another's honey.
But in the end,
it's just flavor...
as nourishing as,
golden money.

Joined
06 Nov 15
Moves
41301
17 May 20
1 edit

Thank you Ponderable!

I've bumped your results for convenience.

----------------------

So here are the results, I invite everybody to double-check and I will fire up the second round Voting thread in the eraly afternoon.

Results:

1 Release 28
2 Dogma 23
3 A reason to live 22
4 This little piggy 21
----------------------------
5 In which Reginald goes for a walk 20
6 Billy Southgate 11
7 Lockdown 10
8 Beyond the Horizon 8
Soulsearching 8
10 Victoria's Wedding 6
11 Mr. Wilson's board Meeting 2
Rose coloured glasses 2
13 Escape 1
14 LUCKY ME!
Cynthia

As it Looks now it would have been nice if the Reginald Story would have made the cut, but alas, the rules were fixed before.

PAR

The World

Joined
16 May 13
Moves
146307
17 May 20

What duration is planned for the second round of voting?

I assume if there is ultimately a draw that a third round will be needed.

Is 3 days long enough? Or a full week?

The Ghost Chamber

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
28736
17 May 20
1 edit

@paul-a-roberts said
What duration is planned for the second round of voting?

I assume if there is ultimately a draw that a third round will be needed.

Is 3 days long enough? Or a full week?
I'm sure Ponderable, the splendid fellow that he is, will enlighten us shortly.

The Ghost Chamber

Joined
14 Mar 15
Moves
28736
17 May 20

@wolfe63 said
Did you even vote?

Anyway, criteria dependent decisions were not easily made.

One man's candy,
can taste sweeter than...
another's honey.
But in the end,
it's just flavor...
as nourishing as,
golden money.
I believe Wolfgang is saving his powder for the final round.

😆

Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined
09 Jun 07
Moves
48793
17 May 20

@wolfe63 said
Did you even vote?
Yes.

chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
656282
17 May 20

Actually we didn't specify this. I would still give a week.

Now I will set up the voting, so you can enjoy the final results next Sunday at Tea time 😉

chemist

Linkenheim

Joined
22 Apr 05
Moves
656282
17 May 20

@ponderable said
Actually we didn't specify this. I would still give a week.

Now I will set up the voting, so you can enjoy the final results next Sunday at Tea time 😉
Well I missed to set the correct time, so it is only three days. However the first ten votes are in.

IP

Joined
15 Jun 10
Moves
46270
18 May 20

Thought this needed a quick bump.

IP

Joined
15 Jun 10
Moves
46270
20 May 20

It's getting bumpy again.

Quiz Master

RHP Arms

Joined
09 Jun 07
Moves
48793
20 May 20

@ghost-of-a-duke said
I believe Wolfgang is saving his powder for the final round.

😆
I voted by PM in the first round as I didn't want to influence anyone.
I believe I was the second person to vote.