07 Jun '07 14:39>1 edit
Originally posted by Dragon FireThe mods check game opening to see how long the game stays in data and don't even bother running those moves or considering them at all. Games may drop out of data, go back into data, drop out, come back... and that is all ignored. That is pretty much into early or middle 'middle game'.
I can certainly agree that engine matches scored in the middle or end game are (or at least should be) significantly more damning than matches scored whilst in the opening as in the former case there is a good chance those matches were achieved as a result of legitimate past analysis whilst that clearly is not possible in the middle and end game. ...[text shortened]... one can "learn" middle game / end game play from an engine without actually using an engine.
From that point only are the moves analyzed over several games... and more if needed. That is how a case is built. If there is any question or doubts, game mods keep checking.
Game mods don't compare anything going on in the open unless the game doesn't match any established data available to them. Many users have claimed they have a vast database based on moves the leave opening theory, but just how plausible is that? I doubt there are many very strong players that have developed an all encompassing database based on their opponant doing a weak move in the opening.
Again, any user claiming their database was perhaps polluted by an engine are just making excuses for their play. There are far too many lines that can be played to say you have data to answer all bad moves in an open or early middle game.
When the moves match "engine moves" move after move, game after game chances are this person is using an engine. Admins do not remove this user until the evidence is overwhelming, so 'benefit of the doubt' is long out the door by this time considering the amount of time spent on the case and the evidence compiled.
Users are given the benefit of the doubt, that is why more and more games are looked at before anyone is removed from the site.
P-