Go back
Best murder

Best murder

Posers and Puzzles

S

Joined
27 Jun 04
Moves
602
Clock
19 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Try and figure this out geniuses.
A man living on the third floor steps into an elevator with no one on it. It makes no stops, I repeat, no stops untill it reaches the first floor. It doesn't go below the first floor or above the third. But when he gets out, HE IS DEAD. PERIOD.

P
Upward Spiral

Halfway

Joined
02 Aug 04
Moves
8702
Clock
19 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

By first floor do you mean the ground floor?

S

Joined
27 Jun 04
Moves
602
Clock
19 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I mean the first floor. There is a basement. But the elevator doesn't stop there. It doesn't go to the basement.

S

Joined
27 Jun 04
Moves
602
Clock
19 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Doesn't anyone have any ideas?! It is fairly easy to answer.

a
Enola Straight

mouse mouse mouse

Joined
16 Jan 05
Moves
12804
Clock
19 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

How could he get out of the elevator if he is dead?

TP
Leak-Proof

under the sink

Joined
08 Aug 04
Moves
12493
Clock
19 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Shoskavitch
Try and figure this out geniuses.
A man living on the third floor steps into an elevator with no one on it. It makes no stops, I repeat, no stops untill it reaches the first floor. It doesn't go below the first floor or above the third. But when he gets out, HE IS DEAD. PERIOD.
Not sure where you're going with this, but in addition to Ark13's excellent question, I have a few others.

You said he lives on the third floor, but didn't say what floor he was on when he entered the elevator.
You didn't say that he got out on the first floor (or as Ark13 pointed out, how as a dead man he managed to get out).
You didn't say that no one else stepped onto the elevator at the third floor.

BigDogg
Secret RHP coder

on the payroll

Joined
26 Nov 04
Moves
155080
Clock
20 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Shoskavitch
Doesn't anyone have any ideas?! It is fairly easy to answer.
A bit too easy to answer. Maybe a sniper shot him from across the street. Maybe there was poisonous fumes in the elevator. Maybe somebody cut the elevator cord or it snapped. It seems a few methods of death are possible, but perhaps I'm missing something.

Oh, and maybe he slumped against the door after the sniper shot him, and 'got out' by falling out once the door opened at the bottom.

F
9 Edits

London

Joined
28 Sep 04
Moves
110329
Clock
20 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

its sooooo obvious...he shot himself...it's really not that difficult to answer!

F
9 Edits

London

Joined
28 Sep 04
Moves
110329
Clock
20 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

or perhaps.....there was a hole in the floor of the elevator!

fred

P

Joined
30 Dec 04
Moves
168686
Clock
20 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

OK, he's in the elevator. Doesn't go above 3rd, doesn't go beow 1st.

I reckon it's violently shaking up and down between 1st and 3rd. He dies of a brain haemorrhage caused by "lift drift". He leans against the elevator door, stiff as a board, until someone opens it.

Any one of several million answers.

OK, so what's the real one? Put us out of our misery......

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26758
Clock
21 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Maybe somebody cut the elevator cord

That's what I'm going with. The cord was either cut so as to barely be able to hold the elevator car, but not the car plus a person, or someone cut the cord as the man got in.

Or, depending on how an "elevator" is defined, maybe there was no floor!

In any case, the man died due to falling two stories.

MS

Under Cover

Joined
25 Feb 04
Moves
28912
Clock
21 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

He was 87 years old. When he stepped out of the elevator, he was face to "face" with the models from this year's SI Swimsuit edition in their painted on garb....Heart Attack...instantly.

k
The Knights rules

Joined
20 May 04
Moves
5392
Clock
21 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

He was dead when he entered

mwmiller
RHP Member No.16

Joined
25 Feb 01
Moves
104486
Clock
21 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

His killer got on the elevator right after him, on the same floor.

kk

Sunny Morecambe

Joined
01 Jan 05
Moves
7100
Clock
21 Feb 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Shoskavitch
Try and figure this out geniuses.
A man living on the third floor steps into an elevator with no one on it. It makes no stops, I repeat, no stops untill it reaches the first floor. It doesn't go below the first floor or above the third. But when he gets out, HE IS DEAD. PERIOD.
The elevator doors slammed shut on him, squishing him into a pancake, and he falls out dead?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.