Go back
Math Puzzles: Try to solve this problem

Math Puzzles: Try to solve this problem

Posers and Puzzles

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by smaia
You will be amazed how beautiful and simple the solution is.
No need to use calculators or perform complex computations.
It can be resolved mentally if you discover a few hidden things.
I got about 19.85 degrees, but i want to find the nice simple way
(there are omitted degrees symbols....)

let x = AB = BC = AC
BD = DC = x/2

using simple trig, BED = 50 deg, EBD = 60 deg, BDE = 70 deg

ED/sin(60) = (x/2)/sin(50) (sine rule)
ED = x*sin(60)/sin(50) = sqroot(3)*x/(2sin(50))

sqr(EC) = sqr(ED) + sqr(DC) - 2*ED*DC*cos(110) (cosine rule, 110 deg from basic trig)
EC = sqroot(3sqr(x)/(4sqr(sin(50))) + sqr(x)/4 - 2 * sqroot(3)*sqr(x)/(4sin(50)) * cos(110)) = 1.39x

DC/sin(DEC) = EC/sin(110)
sin(DEC) = x/2 * sin(110)/EC
DEC = 19.849404914... degrees

very messy....

correct me if im wrong please

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by smaia
If you want to follow your approach, you need to set AB = x where x is any real number.
No you don't - the angles will be the same for any similar triangle. You can pick whatever value is most convenient. 1, for instance.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sb3700
I got about 19.85 degrees, but i want to find the nice simple way
(there are omitted degrees symbols....)

let x = AB = BC = AC
BD = DC = x/2

using simple trig, BED = 50 deg, EBD = 60 deg, BDE = 70 deg

ED/sin(60) = (x/2)/sin(50) (sine rule)
ED = x*sin(60)/sin(50) = sqroot(3)*x/(2sin(50))

sqr(EC) = sqr(ED) + sqr(DC) - 2*ED*DC*cos(110) (cosine rul ...[text shortened]... * sin(110)/EC
DEC = 19.849404914... degrees

very messy....

correct me if im wrong please
can you resolve that mentally with no need for complex calculations, as the poster of this problem said the solution is simple ( manageable in the mind). If you can do all of that in your head, your the man. if i had to guess, your solution is not of the simple variety, just a thought😵

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Angle DEC is 50 degrees, break down all the triangles within the triangle.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by mtthw
No you don't - the angles will be the same for any similar triangle. You can pick whatever value is most convenient. 1, for instance.
True, but assume you are not allowed to use a calculator.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sb3700
I got about 19.85 degrees, but i want to find the nice simple way
(there are omitted degrees symbols....)

let x = AB = BC = AC
BD = DC = x/2

using simple trig, BED = 50 deg, EBD = 60 deg, BDE = 70 deg

ED/sin(60) = (x/2)/sin(50) (sine rule)
ED = x*sin(60)/sin(50) = sqroot(3)*x/(2sin(50))

sqr(EC) = sqr(ED) + sqr(DC) - 2*ED*DC*cos(110) (cosine rul ...[text shortened]... * sin(110)/EC
DEC = 19.849404914... degrees

very messy....

correct me if im wrong please
Nice try, but sorry, this is not the correct answer. You don't need to develop such amazingly complicated calculations to solve this problem.
I assure you: all you need is
1- the sum of the internal angles of a triangle is 180
2- The properties of similar triangles
3- the opposite angles of two intersecting lines are equal and other axioms of euclidian geometry

Good luck.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

*edit* nevermind

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

...

Vote Up
Vote Down

hence the:
" but i want to find the nice simple way"

similar triangles hey......

Vote Up
Vote Down

has it been 2 weeks yet....

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by smaia
True, but assume you are not allowed to use a calculator.
Again, irrelevant. It's about similifying your expressions.

I got (first attempt - will check it later):

DEC = arctan[sin(50)sin(70)/(sin(50)cos(70) + sin(60))]

No calculators in sight. Clearly not the 'simple' method you're looking for, though.

Vote Up
Vote Down

From the AD segment, draw a 20 degrees line that intersects AB at a point E.
As I understand it there is no single answer.


The quotation above has no restrictions on choosing the point E.

You can manage it so that point E is point B, hence the requested angle is 0.

What am I missing?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by TheMaster37
What am I missing?
You're missing his clarification in a later post 🙂

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by mtthw
You're missing his clarification in a later post 🙂
Ah, shame that I should miss that post :p

2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by mtthw
Again, irrelevant. It's about similifying your expressions.

I got (first attempt - will check it later):

DEC = arctan[sin(50)sin(70)/(sin(50)cos(70) + sin(60))]

No calculators in sight. Clearly not the 'simple' method you're looking for, though.
I came up with:

Angle CED = arccot { [ 2 (sin 60) - (sin 110) (cos 50) ] / [ (sin 110) (sin 50) ] }

which is equiivent with yours and smasia's first post

appx. = 32.544

if three of us agree then maybe his solution is flawed

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.