Originally posted by Alcra
Is sex involved? NO

Will either LDY or MNB kill MNA? (hoping to get a yes rather than a maybe!)
Will the person who kills MNA be glad that he is dead?
Is the method by which MNA will be killed relevant?
Are all three people normal living human beings (not mutants. aliens, tv characters etc)?
Are any of the three people diseased?
Are any of the three people deranged?
Are any (or all) of the people related (either genetically or by marriage) to each other?

Will either LDY or MNB kill MNA? (hoping to get a yes rather than a maybe!) YES
Will the person who kills MNA be glad that he is dead? IRRELEVANT
Is the method by which MNA will be killed relevant? NO
Are all three people normal living human beings (not mutants. aliens, tv characters etc)? NO
Are any of the three people diseased? NO
Are any of the three people deranged? NO
Are any (or all) of the people related (either genetically or by marriage) to each other? YES

Originally posted by darvlay
Korean couple runs a convenient store on the wrong side of the tracks. While closing up, a single masked man enters the store waving a saturday night special and demanding the cash be given to him.

"Ders-a no munny heah!" the Korean man yells and slowly reaches for the 12-gauge stashed underneath the #8 plastic bags.

The masked man sense danger a ...[text shortened]... tching the fresh wound. His wife cries over him as the fade to black begins.

Am I close?

Originally posted by Alcra
Will either LDY or MNB kill MNA? (hoping to get a yes rather than a maybe!) YES
Will the person who kills MNA be glad that he is dead? IRRELEVANT
Is the method by which MNA will be killed relevant? NO
Are all three people normal living hu ...[text shortened]... ple related (either genetically or by marriage) to each other? YES

Will the person who kills MNA be forced to kill him as the only feasible action? YES
Is MNA a normal living human being (not a mutant. alien, tv character etc)? NO
Is MNB a normal human being as above? NO
Is LDY a normal human being as above? NO
Are their any husband / wife pairs in the group? YES
Are there any siblings in the group? NO
Are there any twins in the group? NO
Are there any triplets in the group? NO
Are there any parent / children pairs in the group? NO

Are the two men Siamese twins and the lady the surgeon about to separate them. Only one can survive the op cos they share vital bits???

Originally posted by jimslyp69
Are the two men Siamese twins and the lady the surgeon about to separate them. Only one can survive the op cos they share vital bits???

Originally posted by Alcra
Will the person who kills MNA be forced to kill him as the only feasible action? YES
Is MNA a normal living human being (not a mutant. alien, tv character etc)? NO
Is MNB a normal human being as above? NO
Is LDY a normal human being as above? NO
Are their any husband / wife pairs in the group? YES
Are there any siblings in the group? NO
Are there any ...[text shortened]...
Are there any triplets in the group? NO
Are there any parent / children pairs in the group? NO

Is LDY married to MNA?
Is LDY married to MNB?
Is the scenario related to a known work of fiction / film etc?
Is anyone in the scenario an alien?
Is the scenario related to religion?
In the scenario, is everyone alive?
In the scenario, is everyone human?
Will the person who kills MNA save another's life by that action?

Is a parachute involved in the scheme of things?

Just to summarise first, to avoid later confusion. MNA is going to die. None of the people are real, but they are human.

Is LDY married to MNA? NO
Is LDY married to MNB? YES
Is the scenario related to a known work of fiction / film etc? TO BROAD
Is anyone in the scenario an alien? NO
Is the scenario related to religion? YES (I had to think about this one quite hard)
In the scenario, is everyone alive? DEFINE ALIVE
In the scenario, is everyone human? YES (see above)
Will the person who kills MNA save another's life by that action? Maybe

NO

Originally posted by darvlay
It's a double murder-suicide! Like my first post, the story of the jealous husband, the scene begins with the jealous husband already having killed MNA and LDY (MNB and LDY are married and MNA was the best man at the wedding.) He realizes that he would rather die than go to prison. He turns the gun on himself and it's at that moment that he knows his life is over.

Am I close?

So, LDY is Married to MNB:
Is there any connection of MNA to MDB or LDY (work collegue, employed by, friend, vicar at wedding etc) that is relevant?

Did the scenario really happen?

Was the scenario invented for the purposes of this puzzle only?

Does the scenario come up in another context to that of this puzzle?

Would knowing the way that this scenario is related to religion help us significantly in finding the answer?

If you imagine the setup of the scenario as if it was really happening now, are you imagining normal living human beings?

Will the killing of MNA benefit the person who kills him significantly?

Will the killing of MNA benefit anyone other than the person who kills him significantly?