Originally posted by KellyJay
I read about the rulers being laying end to end, and didn't think it
addressed the question at all. If there were 12 rulers and you moved each
one whatever it takes to equal a 12 inches of space between them, you may
as well just stick another ruler on one end and not move them. It is still
having the rulers slide apart into new space. There has to be s ...[text shortened]... upies more cubic inches of space has
that balloon moving into space it wasn't in before.
Kelly
Space isn't expanding into space. It IS space.
Space is [probably] infinite. AND space is expanding...
The best analogy I can think of is to use the natural number line.
At time zero, the number line consists only of integers.
Each integer represents an atom in space, and they are all bunched up right next to each other.
Then at time one, the number line expands to include numbers with 1 decimal point.
Now each integer [atom] has 9 decimal numbers between it and the next integer.
The number line has expanded without expanding into anything and while still being infinitely long.
At time two, the number line expands to include numbers with 2 decimal points...
And so on and so fourth.
The natural number line isn't expanding into anything, and it started off being infinitely big.
But at each interval the space between integers grows larger [exponentially so].
Now that is not to say that our space, our universe might not be part of some larger hyperspace.
Some hypotheses [eg: String/M Theory] suggest that that might be the case, but we have no
direct or conclusive evidence of or for that yet.
But standard cosmology says that the space we live in IS all there is, and that there is no larger
space around it, and nothing for our space to be expanding into.
The thing with the balloon analogy is to realise that it is JUST an analogy, and you can't disregard
the part where someone says 'now imagine the universe is the surface of the balloon'. You have to
pretend there is no 'space' around [or inside] the surface of the balloon for the analogy to work.