Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Insult??? its the equivalent of General Grievous calling Anakin Skywalker, 'Jedi scum!'
It's the equivalent of anyone using the label of the 'other side' as an insult, at any time or place in history.
A good example would be the use of atheist as an insult....
In this case this would be me trying to find a word I can use (that this site lets me) that encompasses the
exasperation I feel at those who abandon all logic and reason and cease to value evidence and observation
in favour of fairy tales and wishful thinking while wasting their lives in honour of the goblin king while trying
to get everyone else to do it and persecuting those that don't....
And I suddenly discovered that there was a word that encompassed all that.
Theist.
I am an Atheist, and I am one for a reason, and the things that I value that make me an atheist are the things
that all theists must abandon to be a theist.
Thus Theist is the word that accurately targets the specific thing I dislike, and nothing else.
Put it this way, I hate smoking, the smell of the cigarettes, no the stench of the cigarettes, makes me choke, the
smoke makes it hard to breath, and that's before you get to the health issues.
However I know some perfectly lovely smokers, with whom I am friends.
I think their smoking is idiotic, but calling them an idiot impunes more than just the thing I object to.
In the same way, any insult levelled at someone for being a theist, for throwing away reason and evidence, for
all the ills of religion, will inevitably imply defects of character or behaviour beyond the religious/theistic ones that I
am aiming at.
All but one, the one word that hits only what I am aiming at is the label for what it is I object to. Theist/theism itself.
So, Yes I use Theist as an insult. In much the same way as many theists use Atheism as an insult.
And in much the same way as I wear Atheist as a badge of honour, I have no doubt those who I call Theist will wear that
with equal pride.
But it's the only word I can think of that only attacks those things I actually want to attack. At least from my point of view.