Originally posted by LemonJello Thank you for your clarifications in this thread. I understand better now how according to your view it makes sense to say S1 and S2 are the same person.
Your view seems more self-consistent in this respect than what RJHinds has described.
Well thanks. But it's really not my view but I know what you mean. All JW's have this same understanding from the Bible and pretty much can show by scriptures this belief.
It's all in the Bible but one does need some help from God's spirit to see it clearly. So let me know what else I can do for you....
Originally posted by LemonJello Thank you for your clarifications in this thread. I understand better now how according to your view it makes sense to say S1 and S2 are the same person.
Your view seems more self-consistent in this respect than what RJHinds has described.
Originally posted by RJHinds Why don't you become a JW then?
Uh, because I think their core beliefs are nuts.
Just because, based on his clarifications, I do not see any obvious contradiction in his view that S1 and S2 are the same person doesn't mean I think the JW take on how the world works has any actual basis in facts. I also think the idea that the moon is made of cheese is self-consistent. Does that mean I should adopt that view?
Your view seems incoherent, though. I've already given some reasons why I think that.
Originally posted by LemonJello Uh, because I think their core beliefs are nuts.
Just because, based on his clarifications, I do not see any obvious contradiction in his view that S1 and S2 are the same person doesn't mean I think the JW take on how the world works has any actual basis in facts. I also think the idea that the moon is made of cheese is self-consistent. Does that m ...[text shortened]... iew?
Your view seems incoherent, though. I've already given some reasons why I think that.
I have never heard a JW say the moon is made of cheese.
Calling out galveston75
22 Apr '13 20:52
Back to Top