17 Apr '13 21:58>
In another thread I posed the following question to you. You exhibited some concern that it would be taking the thread off-course, so I started a new thread.
I am asking because I am interested in discussion related to the subject of personal identity and the question of what exactly makes some person one and the same person over time. Honestly, I don't understand what you think makes S2 numerically identical to S1.
According to your beliefs, person S1 dies at natural death and nothing of S1 survives this. Then, sometime later, God creates a "resurrected" person S2 that based on His memory is supposed to bear some intimate relation to S1. But, I am asking what reasons you have for thinking that S2 is numerically identical to S1; rather than thinking that S2 is simply a new person distinct from S1. This question deals with the subject of personal identity and what exactly makes some person one and the same person over time.
Basically, why are the persons who supposedly get created and set up down the road in earthly paradise simply not new distinct persons?
I am asking because I am interested in discussion related to the subject of personal identity and the question of what exactly makes some person one and the same person over time. Honestly, I don't understand what you think makes S2 numerically identical to S1.