Originally posted by Coletti
Think of TOE as a vector with a clear direction- up - from bugs to people. For any genetic mutation (or series of mutations) to be evidence of TOE, it must point in the same direction. But so far, the mutations could be going in any direction, up down or sideways. Data is added and subtracted at random. Random mutations. Maybe our ancestors will be amoebas!
TOE as a vector pointing from bugs to humans...humans did not evolve from the bugs that exist now by the TOE, but let's say a vector from the bugs we did evolve from (according to the TOE) to humans. That's a minor point.
However, here's a more major point - According to the TOE, cheetahs also evolved from the same bugs. However the vector you propose (bugs to humans, or BTH) would point in a different direction at some point than the one which would point from bugs to cheetahs (BTC). This vector concept of yours doesn't work since the TOE encompasses phenomena other than those directly involved in the hypothesized evolution of humans. Both BTH and BTC are part of the TOE, as are the evolutions of every other form of life on the planet.
But so far, the mutations could be going in any direction, up down or sideways.
If the "mutations can go up" does that mean information can be added without intelligent intervention? The original claim, I think, claims that under no circumstances, ever, can "mutations go up" unless a human or some other ID (God, basically) is conciously, intentionally causing this to happen.
The TOE does agree that mutations happen at random. However, the process of natural selection is what directs evolution, once mutations add variation to the gene pool. There's no evidence to suggest natural selection would favor a change in the human species to become ameobas over time.
Using your imagery, the TOE claims mutations go randomly "up", "down", "sideways", etc. However natural selection caused those went "down" and "sideways" to either evolve into a different species or to die out and fail to reproduce. Those which went "up" were consistently successful at reproduction, and over time the accumulation of "up" mutations led to humanity.