Originally posted by twhitehead
If we trace back through the process of your 'willing' (when making a free will decision) then either we ultimately come to something prior to your existence that caused you to 'will' in that way, or your free will decision was at some level uncaused.
I just think the concept of a free will (under certain definitions) is incompatible with a deterministic ...[text shortened]... cisions, then the creator of that initial state is directly responsible for those decisions.
It is no different than processes put in place, we can have a robot to do as it is
programmed to do as we desire. All of its outputs and actions would be caused due
to the inputs we say it must react too, it would act as we have programmed it to.
As it runs into various and sundry inputs its actions would be planned out in
advance, if it runs into something unaccounted for it would either error out or do
something not accounted for in its programming. Its unaccounted for action would
still be it acting out due to programming we put into it, it would just do whatever
action does because it has to act because of its programming.
With humans and our wills we can be bound by our nature, we can be bound by
the peer pressures around us, we can be bound by the natural world around us, but
with the term free will we can also repent, we can change our minds. We can do
as we will. Now if you want to suggest we are bound by our creator to act as we
do than you are not talking about freewill but robots, if you acknowledge that God
gave us a will to do as we will given choices to act upon, than again even our
free will came by cause which is the desire of our creator.
If you choose to say no God allowed in this discussion than there is no such thing
as free will in my opinion, we are simply products of a lot of accidents, which again
is a cause.
Kelly