Go back
Conflict between Mormon and Biblical teachings

Conflict between Mormon and Biblical teachings

Spirituality


@Suzianne

So does it say that what I said is wrong or correct?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@hakima said
I am the eldest of eight siblings raised in the Mormon church. My parents determined to provide us with as much of a diverse opportunity to know and explore our own minds and consciences as possible. We had regular discussions around the dinner table about religious ideas and were free to speak our minds. To date, exactly half of us have left the church, but not one is shunned ...[text shortened]... apada or the Bhagavadgita. I find tgat I glean from each as much as I bring when I open their pages.
I had heard that shunning was a part of the theology -- I guess that I must stand partially corrected! I am glad that you did not experience any of this, but this is why there are people who say that shunning is a common enough occurrence -- so your statement "No where in Mormon theology nor policy is there any indication that families should shun those who choose to leave[/i] is not an entirely accurate statement, either.

So, I took a look, and it is:

A parade of anti-Christs, anti-Mormons, and apostate groups have appeared on the scene. Many are still among us and have released new floods of lies and false accusations. These faith-killers and testimony-thieves use personal contacts, the printed word, electronic media, and other means of communication to sow doubts and to disturb the peace of true believers…Avoid those who would tear down your faith. Faith-killers are to be shunned. The seeds which they plant in the minds and hearts of men grow like cancer and eat away the Spirit.


Carlos E. Asay, General Conference, October 1981

Drugs, drink, pornographic materials, and subculture associations are also escape routes. …Shun those who would build themselves by destroying others.


Marvin J. Ashton, General Conference, 1988 (though this seems less clear if the quotation is being used in a way that is a definitive command.)

Here:

Contextualization: "During the temple interview, this question is asked of the member, "Do you support, affiliate with, or agree with any group or individual whose teachings or practices are contrary to or oppose those accepted by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints?" The answer to this question must be "No," or the member will fail the interview. Some members feel that to answer this question they must avoid contact with certain people. This can lead to shunning those people."

Quotation:

Essential to your success and happiness is the advice "Choose your friends with caution." We tend to become like those whom we admire, and they are usually our friends. We should associate with those who, like us, are planning not for temporary convenience, shallow goals, or narrow ambition—but rather with those who value the things that matter most, even eternal objectives.


Thomas S. Monson, General Conference, 2005

A Reddit post from "Ex-Mormon" is simply entitled:

"Shunning in Mormonism *is* officially taught (though only selectively enforced.)"

https://www.reddit.com/r/exmormon/comments/5oj2eh/shunning_in_mormonism_is_officially_taught_though/

Here is another article that involves the concept of shunning:

In my own exodus from Mormonism the culture of shunning quickly became apparent, from formerly close siblings who quit communicating with me, to a bishop who encouraged my (now ex) wife to divorce me. Within weeks of leaving, very few ward members would even talk to me. Several times, when I was grocery shopping, a ward member would see me, turn around and go the other way. It was heart rending. This is not an uncommon occurrence as reported to me by many of my ex-Mormon friends.


https://transitioningfrommormonism.blogspot.com/2015/10/mormonism-culture-of-shunning.html
List:
http://www.mormonthink.com/QUOTES/shunning.htm

Some more illumination on this:

Vote Up
Vote Down

Vote Up
Vote Down

@Philokalia

Mormons are not all the same. I would imagine how strict they are depends greatly on the region of the country and the type of mormons.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@eladar said
Moonbus wanted to know if I knew anything about Mormon beliefs so I started this thread.
Aren't you, by your own definition, "abusing" and "attacking" Mormons, though?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@FMF

By stating what they believe? Or is it the contrasting it to what the Bible states?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@eladar said
@FMF

By stating what they believe?
By making it clear you believe something different.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@FMF

No. If I were to call it a fairy tale or something like that then yes. But to contrast what I believe with what they believe is not abusive at all.

Sad you cannot tell the difference.


@eladar said
@FMF

Or is it the contrasting it to what the Bible states?
If Mormons believe in Jesus and therefore self-identify as Christians, I accept that, just like I accept it when you say you believe in Jesus and self-identify as a Christian.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@eladar said
@FMF

No. If I were to call it a fairy tale or something like that then yes. But to contrast what I believe with what they believe is not abusive at all.

Sad you cannot tell the difference.
I'm talking about how you appeared to define being "abusive" and "attacking" someone's beliefs in the exchange on moonbus and his sister. Far from supposedly not being able to tell any difference, I seem to be more able to recall and discern the implications of the hypocritical things you blurt out than you are.

1 edit

@FMF

You can have a simplistic view by defining Jesus by name.

I have shown you what they mean by Jesus. Surely even you can see they are totally different entities.

You can see that God the Father is a totally diffetent entity as well.

But you are free to accept them as a form of Christianity as well. I would expect you to. It fits your belief system.


1 edit

@FMF

You are as blind as they come. If moonbus had told his sister they have totally different points of view and accordimg to her beliefs he is not going to be seen in heaven he would have done as I do now.

Even if he had said according to his beliefs heaven does not exist, that would be what I am doing now.


-Removed-
He has also stated that he doesn't care if people go to hell, which seems a tad incongruous with the whole 'love thy neighbour' thing.

1 edit

@divegeester

Then surely you agree that you are not a christian who is like me.