Go back
Does proof of God smack of coercion?

Does proof of God smack of coercion?

Spirituality

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
My usage was clearly the 'generic you'.

[What about thinking you (generic you, could be anyone) were in the Yakuza? Isn't that delusional?]

Why do you guys make me jump through hoops just to explain something? Did you skip primary school?

It's a delay tactic, so that everyone reading this forgets what the point was. That one strategy is about all your (you and FMF) posting habits consist of (I mean besides attacking anyone who disagrees with you or criticizes you).

Meanwhile, this [Go on, flip the switch, make the connection. You can do it!] gets totally lost in translation.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
Is it really "overriding" free will, when Pharoah would have hardened his own heart anyways? He made the decision he would always make, heart-hardening or no.
Then why bother hardening his heart? Why did God find that necessary if you are correct about Pharoah hardening his own heart?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
How can one DECIDE not to believe something that has been proven to your face? No free will. You are now in the position of being FORCED to believe in God. Force = Coercion.
Like Moses was when God appeared to him in a burning bush?


@ghost-of-a-duke said
Well, we thought that of Anakin Skywalker.
Fit's the topic. Lots of Biblical reflections. Was Anakin coerced into going to the dark side of the force? Good and Evil = Light and Darkness? Apparently we, inherently, must all have within us the capacity for either. Why is there evil in the world? Because God made it so? Knowledge can be used for good, or for evil. Iron can be beaten into a plowshare, or into a sword. Or today, more dramatically and of a more tremendous and widespread effect, Atomic energy used for peaceful use in energy generation, or used for war and destruction in atomic bombs. Evil is needed as the antagonist to Good, said Socrates. He also said that since there is no room for evil in heaven, it was cast down to earth.

Star Wars.....and there was war in heaven....Michael fought against Lucifer, and....... our child of the Morning, Light Side of the Force Anakin, went to the Dark Side as Darth Vader. And so Lucifer is also the Evening Star.....

And since Lucifer also refers to the planet Venus, also known as the Goddess of Love, good and evil love each other, since they can't live one without the other. The yin and the yang......

Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
Do you realize how weak that is?
I don't think it is weak at all. Trying to take certain cognitive functions of the mind and sprinkle some sort of supernatural dust upon them by attributing them to a different organ in the human body - because sometimes writers do so when they write metaphorically - is a rhetorical gimmick in a discussion like this.

1 edit

@suzianne said
You're adamant about ignoring a well-known colloquialism.
Yes I am if it is obfuscating the reality of what happening and romanticizing it instead. Cognitive activity occurs in the brain, which is host to the mind, and not in the heart - which pumps blood.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
How are you so unable to grasp simple concepts?

This is a weak strategy, akin to you quoting a word or two followed by a question mark, like you don't understand anything. Maybe a break from the stresses of an online forum is in the cards for you. (cue the "cards? what are you on about?" response) If you can't understand anything that is said, perhaps you should hang up this stressful hobby you can't understand anymore.
This was the fifth response to me in a row on page 8 that was making quips about my intelligence instead of tackling the points you were supposedly replying to.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
My usage was clearly the 'generic you'.[What about thinking you (generic you, could be anyone) were in the Yakuza? Isn't that delusional?]
I was never in the Yakuza. I am British.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@suzianne said
You are coerced to believe through the evidence of proof. Once proven, you have no choice (no free will) but to believe.
Was Thomas coerced by Jesus?

2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
If I thought I'd been in the Yakuza, then that would be delusional. Otherwise, if I claimed that was ever in the Yakuza, it would have had to have been either a lie or a joke.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.