Originally posted by LemonJello
[b]I do not think any true Christian beliefs are irrational (the Christian world view does not contain contradictory beliefs) and is completely logic.
lack of contradiction between beliefs is not sufficient for the belief system to be rational. what evidence do you have that the christian beliefs are 'completely logic'? if they are, then they a ...[text shortened]... ly not completely rational. furthermore, being complete and being correct are not the same.
[/b]
then since christian beliefs are 'completely logic' (from above), it follows from transitivity that christian beliefs cannot answer any questions.
I meant to say "logical", not "logic". When I say something is fully rational, or logical, I mean that the premises and their logical conclusions are non-contradictory. "Logic" is the method by which we determine if a given set of propositions are rational (logical). Logic itself is not the object of reasoning, it is the means of reasoning. The content of logical operations that are considered rational (logical).
if the christian god is a supernatural being; and if the supernatural is beyond our intellect and unknowable through reason; then how is the christian's belief in the christian god rational?
I do not agree with the premise the "the supernatural is beyond our intellect and unknowable through reason."
you've said before that your world view is complete (in a different thread). now you are saying it is also completely rational. therefore, as your world view is both complete and completely rational, it must be possible for man (specifically, coletti in this case) to explain everything through reason. .
Yes. The Christian world view (CWV) means the axioms of Christianity and their logical conclusions (inferences). Using the axioms of Christianity, and correctly applying logic, one can explain all the fundamental questions about "the meaning of life."
By complete, I mean the CWV can answer all the basic questions regarding epistemology, ethics, metaphysics, etc. It explains the fundamental questions about how can we know things, or explain existence, and morality. It does not leave any of the basic questions unanswered.
however, your world view itself directly contradicts this by saying that, on the contrary, it is not possible for man to explain everything through reason because (in your own words), "man in general is flawed, he makes mistakes in reasoning...man's mind is finite."
This does not contradict the CWV. On one hand I am saying that the CWV can answer all things about life and morality. I do not mean to say it can answer all questions - such as what tie you should wear to your next job interview - but the most fundamental ones. On the other hand I was speaking about the finite capacity for man to know and understand. Man is not the CWV or God. People are flawed, and make mistakes in reasoning. I was talking about two different things.
so your world view is definitely not both complete and completely rational.
In summary - the Christian world view is both compete and rational. It can answer all the basic questions of existence and purpose and knowledge, and it is rational because it is non-contradictory. I know of no alternative world view that can make this claim.