Originally posted by jaywill
[b]============================
If God is not real to me, then sin is a nonsensical concept. Your argument is circular.
=================================
But sin is real to you even if God is not real to you.
If you did not think so ask yourself, are there people who have offended you?
If sin is a weak concept or circular why do you some kind of circular reasoning will cause your sins to not be too serious on that day.[/b]
…
If you did not think so ask yourself, are there people who have offended you?
If sin is a weak concept or circular why do you have trouble forgetting some of the things which have been done against you?
Would you say "Well those offences were not sins."
..…
In answer to your last question above, I would say merely being offensive is not how I and probably most people would equate with the word “sin”.
In everyday English, I don’t think most people wouldn’t call merely making some offensive words a “sin”. In fact, the word “sin” can formally mean doing the exact opposite of what “God” tells you to do:
http://www.allaboutgod.com/definition-of-sin.htm
“…If God says "Do not lie" and you lie, then you have sinned. If God says "Do not steal" and you steal, then you have sinned. According to God, sin separates you from Him (Isaiah 59:2)…”
But that means if you are an atheist like me and you don’t believe there exists a “God” then you, like me, wouldn’t believe there is such thing as “sin” in the stated sense above (because there is no “God” to tell you what to do and thus allow you to do the opposite of what “he” says because “he“ wouldn’t exist) and therefore your assertion: -
….But sin is real to you even if God is not real to you. ..…
-with THIS definition of "sin", must logically be false.
However, of course, you could be giving the word “sin” a much wider meaning:
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Sin
“…1. A transgression of a religious or moral law, especially when deliberate.
2. Theology
a. Deliberate disobedience to the known will of God.
b. A condition of estrangement from God resulting from such disobedience.
3. Something regarded as being shameful, deplorable, or utterly wrong….”
-then, at least with definition (3), you cannot imply anything about the existence/non-existence of a “God” by the word “sin” (I am not implying here that this is what you implied) for saying somebody “sinned” wouldn’t, at least with definition (3) above, necessarily imply that there is a “god”.