27 Feb '06 16:03>
Originally posted by LemonJelloIt isn't a merry-go-round with me, it is a topic you and others start
This topic is like a merry-go-round with you. It is a sleight of hand to say that IF death is merely a permanent end to consciousness THEN all actions become meaningless. I think I already posted an example from Nagle concerning "chains of justification" that terminate fully within this natural life:
Suppose your daughter or son unknowingly reaches f ...[text shortened]... certainly don't require external justification that stems from eschatological considerations.
then back off when the questions come.
I didn't say all actions become meaningless, I said everything
becomes meaningless if it all goes to nothing after this life time.
Life matters, everything that does matter only matters in life, where
there isn't life, nothing matters. So of course all examples you give
where I'm going to apply meaning, purpose, value are going to
apply in life, but that isn't what this discussion is about now is it?
It is the window of life, how long is it, and does it stop ever? If the
end of life means that all you are or what you have ever done,
goes up into nothingness, than that is what happens, nothing. It
would not matter after you die to you if you stopped your child from
being hurt, or that you hurt your child, nothing you did matters after
you die according to that belief system, except in this life, and then
it to will wash away as time goes on as those that you touched all
die and go into nothingness too. The selfish life, and the giving one
are equally void at death, they are only meaningful in life, but who
is to say one is worse than the other since they both go to the same
end, and all the effects of both also end up the same way in the
end.
Kelly