01 Jun '10 17:07>4 edits
The knee jerk response made by many theists to the claim that an omnipotent God doesn't stop cancer, rapists etc... and is therefore not perfectly good tends to be of the form
You think god should suspend physics and perform miracles on a second by second basis???
My answer to that would be yes! Given the assumption it is omnipotent then it would be little inconvenience at all for it to do that very thing, and having created a system where nasty things occur then to justify any claim of being perfectly good/loving etc... (assuming these concepts bear any relation to accepted notions of goodness or loving etc...) it is necessary it should act to minimise the sum of all suffering.
Anticipating arguments of the form: "ah but what if god stopping something bad from happening indirectly decreases the amount of good in the world" please tell me how (in detail) this is applicable, say, to the thousands of lives being torn apart or extinguished right now by tropical storm Agatha in Guatemala.
*edit* I acknowledge this thread does not apply to a god that isn't assumed to be perfectly good etc...
You think god should suspend physics and perform miracles on a second by second basis???
My answer to that would be yes! Given the assumption it is omnipotent then it would be little inconvenience at all for it to do that very thing, and having created a system where nasty things occur then to justify any claim of being perfectly good/loving etc... (assuming these concepts bear any relation to accepted notions of goodness or loving etc...) it is necessary it should act to minimise the sum of all suffering.
Anticipating arguments of the form: "ah but what if god stopping something bad from happening indirectly decreases the amount of good in the world" please tell me how (in detail) this is applicable, say, to the thousands of lives being torn apart or extinguished right now by tropical storm Agatha in Guatemala.
*edit* I acknowledge this thread does not apply to a god that isn't assumed to be perfectly good etc...