Job vs karma

Groundhog Day 🙄

Rape is a crime simply because the violation of one's right to choose the person with whom one wants to have sexual intercourse is a crime. Therefore, I repeat that in my opinion rape should be punished severely. I would have no problem at all to help the spirit of such a criminal to escape from its shell.

However, rape is not intrinsically evil: the victim will always remain a victim remembering her abuse during all her life, but some children that come into being as the fruit of rape have the chance to live and enjoy a good life. The children that received the gift of life through the crime of rape, are neither a product of "evil" nor "evil" themselves -they are just innocent, wonderful children;
😵

Originally posted by @dj2becker
So rape is not intrinsically wrong?

Sorry dj2becker, I forgot to reply you with the quote and reply button; my answer to you is my post above😵

Originally posted by @black-beetle
Sorry dj2becker, I forgot to reply you with the quote and reply button; my answer to you is my post above😵

No worries. Would I be correct in assuming that your response to my question is a no? 😵

Becker, how is it decided if it is rape?
The consensus law decides.
Your argument is hollow.

Originally posted by @dj2becker
No worries. Would I be correct in assuming that your response to my question is a no? 😵

No. As I told you earlier, my answer to your question is: It is neither evil, nor non-evil, nor both, nor neither;

It is not intrinsically evil, because rape under certain circumstances becomes the means of the gift of life.
It is not intrinsically non-evil, because rape is definitely a crime under all circumstances.
It is not intrinsically both evil and non-evil, because it cannot be properly said that rape is both a crime and not a crime.
It is intrinsically neither evil and non-evil, because it cannot be properly said that rape is neither a crime nor a non-crime.
😵

Originally posted by @dj2becker
Say whaat? People do bad things between incarnations?

🙄

The good or bad actions of one incarnation will/may impact on the next one. (So a mass murderer in this life may get his comeuppance in his next incarnation,...possibly coming back as your therapist).

Originally posted by @divegeester
Becker, how is it decided if it is rape?
The consensus law decides.
Your argument is hollow.

So you are saying rape in itself is not evil, it is merely wrong because people decided that it is?

Originally posted by @black-beetle
No. As I told you earlier, my answer to your question is: It is neither evil, nor non-evil, nor both, nor neither;

It is not intrinsically evil, because rape under certain circumstances becomes the means of the gift of life.
It is not intrinsically non-evil, because rape is definitely a crime under all circumstances.
It is not intrinsically both e ...[text shortened]... d non-evil, because it cannot be properly said that rape is neither a crime nor a non-crime.
😵

So you are saying rape would be ok if people hadn't agreed that it is wrong?

Originally posted by @ghost-of-a-duke
🙄

The good or bad actions of one incarnation will/may impact on the next one. (So a mass murderer in this life may get his comeuppance in his next incarnation,...possibly coming back as your therapist).

So you think Job was a mass murderer in his previous life? 🙄

Originally posted by @rbhill
Job is a good example of karma being false a lie. Same with the man born blind that Jesus heals.

Your job? I don't even know what you do for a living.

Originally posted by @whodey
Your job? I don't even know what you do for a living.

Either you're really slow or you're joking.

Originally posted by @rbhill
Either you're really slow or you're joking.

Um................................................................yes. 😵

Originally posted by @dj2becker
So you think Job was a mass murderer in his previous life? 🙄

I was attempting to explain karma to you. As always your mind can't process concepts outside of your own narrow way of thinking.

Originally posted by @ghost-of-a-duke
I was attempting to explain karma to you. As always your mind can't process concepts outside of your own narrow way of thinking.

If we are to assume Job is not real why do we consider karma real? Pretty inconsistent of you.