Go back
My God, My God why have you forsaken me.

My God, My God why have you forsaken me.

Spirituality

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Will you please try to refrain from moralising over me. I am merely replying to some pleasantries expressed. Why you should try to make something of that I have no idea. I expect that if the Son of man himself were he you might chastise him also as someone gluttonous, given to drinking wine and a friend of harlots and tax collectors!
Chapter one: zzzzzz

Chapter two: zzzzzz

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sonship
Among those chapters, is there anything Jesus said that you've never fully understood or that you find confusing/contradictory? (Genuine question).


Yes, There are still some things I do not fully understand.
Yes, there are paradoxical statements that are difficult to reconcile with each other.

And I love it. I know that because ...[text shortened]... he word even when I fail to be able to fully explain the word.

Did I answer your question ?
Yes, and it's an answer i can relate to. Probably a weak comparison, but i approach chess in much the same way. (Well, perhaps not the last bit about nourishment). Chess is something that i will never master, and i enjoy learning something new each time i come to it. My game is very much ' a work in progress.' (Though i would of course wipe the floor with Robbie).


Originally posted by sonship
The interesting thing is that the Gospel writer was faithful to include this cry of Jesus. A less than honest propagandist could have figured that it gave fuel to their opposition to Christ's self declaration as God's sent Son.
Where can we find the writings of this supposedly less than honest propagandist you have mentioned?


Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FMF
Where can we find the writings of this supposedly less than honest propagandist you have mentioned?
The Apocrypha.


Originally posted by sonship
The Apocrypha.
To someone who doesn't believe the Bible relates a credible revelation of God, what's the difference between it and "the Apocrypha"?


Hey Robbie. Yeah it's me and I'm still alive. 🙂 I hope you and the family are doing well. Sorry for vanishing on you but the health issues with my parents have gotten worse especially with mom and have been on the road a lot going back and forth to help them. Her Alzheimer's has progressed to the point that we had to admit her into a memory care center a couple months ago for her safety and care. That was by far the hardest day of my life.
She's doing ok but she's so confused and gets so upset when we have to leave after visiting. I don't blame her but even thru it all she isn't mad and still shows us love when and if she remembers us.
Well I don't have any time to play any games now but maybe someday soon once I get dad settled somewhere..... Take care brother.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
Hey Robbie. Yeah it's me and I'm still alive. 🙂 I hope you and the family are doing well. Sorry for vanishing on you but the health issues with my parents have gotten worse especially with mom and have been on the road a lot going back and forth to help them. Her Alzheimer's has progressed to the point that we had to admit her into a memory care center ...[text shortened]... ay any games now but maybe someday soon once I get dad settled somewhere..... Take care brother.
As i'm sure you know, long term memories are more resilient to Alzheimers. I've found music in particular from a persons youth has a wonderful calming affect. Sorry to hear about your mother.


Originally posted by galveston75
Hey Robbie. Yeah it's me and I'm still alive. 🙂 I hope you and the family are doing well. Sorry for vanishing on you but the health issues with my parents have gotten worse especially with mom and have been on the road a lot going back and forth to help them. Her Alzheimer's has progressed to the point that we had to admit her into a memory care center ...[text shortened]... ay any games now but maybe someday soon once I get dad settled somewhere..... Take care brother.
Brother Gman, how good to heart from you, I sent you a private text - regards Robbie 😀

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ghost of a Duke
As i'm sure you know, long term memories are more resilient to Alzheimers. I've found music in particular from a persons youth has a wonderful calming affect. Sorry to hear about your mother.
My first musical memory is Black Betty by Ram Jam



Hopefully if I start to lose it people will play and I'll rock back to consciousness.😵

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Ghost of a Duke
As i'm sure you know, long term memories are more resilient to Alzheimers. I've found music in particular from a persons youth has a wonderful calming affect. Sorry to hear about your mother.
Thanks for the information on that....

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by galveston75
Thanks for the information on that....
I've heard familiar church hymns help too, as well as scripture reading... My father passed away from Dementia a few years ago, it was a sad time indeed. I know what you are going through, my prayers are with you bro.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FMF
To someone who doesn't believe the Bible relates a credible revelation of God, what's the difference between it and "the Apocrypha"?
If you regard all writings concerning Jesus as apocryphal then this must have been a rhetorical question .

Where can we find the writings of this supposedly less than honest propagandist you have mentioned?


To someone who views a questioner as faking interest to conceal an all-encompassing disbelief, what's the difference in answer or not answering him ?

1 edit

Originally posted by sonship
To someone who views a questioner as faking interest to conceal an all-encompassing disbelief, what's the difference in answer or not answering him ?
You said: "The interesting thing is that the Gospel writer was faithful to include this cry of Jesus. A less than honest propagandist could have figured that it gave fuel to their opposition to Christ's self declaration as God's sent Son."

What makes you think that a witness to the execution who did not include the cry of Jesus ~ "My God, My God why have you forsaken me" ~ in his account would necessarily or automatically have been not "honest"?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Jesus was praising until the end. There ere no chapters or verses in the Bible in his days, so first line quotations were given. Any passer by hearing those words should have remembered Psalm 22 and its prophetic application to that moment.