Originally posted by Coletti
That is a misrepresentation of what Ivanhoe said. He said that when doctors can't figure out what's wrong with a patient, they generally diagnose the problem as mental. You have turned that around completely.
Please read his comment in his own words:
Ivanhoe wrote:
It is a well known and sad fact that if regular doctors don't know the cause of the complaints they very quickly turn to the "It Is All Between The Ears" diagnosis. In 99% of the cases this is a translation of "I Don't Have A Clue About What's Going On".
This statement is utter crap. It minimizes the great good that doctors
do, it undermines their humanity (as if they should be able diagnose
all things at all times), and it discredits their
accurate mental
health diagnoses.
Doctors do NOT generally diagnose unknown problems as 'mental;'
this is not some 'well-known fact.' And, often, when they do, the
diagnosis is in some cases correct.
I take his statement as an affront to the medical profession (in which
I have several family members), as well as a tacit minimization of
mental health diagnoses which may or may not have been intended.
Many mental health diagnoses are appropriate (and correct) guesses
in circumstances described by Eagles and, given that NONE of us (but
Eagles) has any detailed information upon which that doctor made his
EXPERT and INFORMED opinion.
That Ivanhoe said it is immaterial. It was an outlandish and
slanderous claim made in a sincere fashion and I won't stand for it.
Nemesio