Originally posted by PinkFloydYeah, I'm not altogether sure there is any correlation.
If meditation and yoga are considered OCD activities, the same as praying, then perhaps your argument is well founded. Since I don't think singing hymns, praying, or studying/reading/discussing ancient writings to be an OCD activity, then I'd disagree with your prermise.
2 edits
Originally posted by PinkFloydI suspect that you may not understand the nature of ritual and/or OCD.
If meditation and yoga are considered OCD activities, the same as praying, then perhaps your argument is well founded. Since I don't think singing hymns, praying, or studying/reading/discussing ancient writings to be an OCD activity, then I'd disagree with your prermise.
Try reading this to get a better grasp:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ritual
Here's an excerpt:
A ritual is a set of actions, performed mainly for their symbolic value. It may be prescribed by a religion or by the traditions of a community. The term usually excludes actions which are arbitrarily chosen by the performers, or dictated purely by logic, chance, necessity, etc...Rituals of various kinds are a feature of almost all known human societies, past or present. They include not only the various worship rites and sacraments of organized religions and cults, but also the rites of passage of certain societies, atonement and purification rites, oaths of allegiance, dedication ceremonies, coronations and presidential inaugurations, marriages and funerals, school "rush" traditions and graduations, club meetings, sports events, Halloween parties, veteran parades, Christmas shopping and more.
In psychology, the term ritual is sometimes used in a technical sense for a repetitive behavior systematically used by a person to neutralize or prevent anxiety; it is a symptom of obsessive-compulsive disorder.
Originally posted by karoly aczelNot sure you've really changed much here. Seems like there's still an avoidance of reality here and where there's an avoidance of reality, there's delusion.
how about this: Because we create the world with our thoughts, it is best to think realistically with a positive outlook. Thats what I try anyway, I cant think of any other way to go...
Originally posted by ThinkOfOneAgain: Realistic interpretation, positive outlook.
Not sure you've really changed much here. Seems like there's still an avoidance of reality here and where there's an avoidance of reality, there's delusion.
I dont see why you cant have a postivive outlook while still embracing and working with ALL that has happened, that is real.
Some (in real life) have said that I seem immature, that I dont fathom the depths of pain, that I make things rosy which aren't.
My life on the outside is not particurlarly rosy. Its always been like that. But just because I have the ability to laugh when contemplating even the most dire of situations does not mean I am deluded. I am finding a way forward. I am working with what I have, and I would do anything in my power to relieve suffering where I can.
I may well laugh, but there is no one more serious when it comes to trying to understand the best and truest "reality" I can fathom. I am realistic with a positive outlook. I really dont want you to think I am one of those new-age scmaltzes that sees everything in a positive light and tries to describe everything as super-easy, but if you do end up thinking that so be it. I cant waste any more time than this post trying to defend my ego- more pressing matters await🙂
Originally posted by karoly aczelWell, based on where you started:
Again: Realistic interpretation, positive outlook.
I dont see why you cant have a postivive outlook while still embracing and working with ALL that has happened, that is real.
Some (in real life) have said that I seem immature, that I dont fathom the depths of pain, that I make things rosy which aren't.
My life on the outside is not particurlarly ...[text shortened]... ant waste any more time than this post trying to defend my ego- more pressing matters await🙂
I dont think OCD is such a bad thing.
Religous fervor can be a good thing. I dont know, I try to see the positive side of things. There is usually a positive side.
Seems likely that you're kidding yourself and me here.
1 edit
Originally posted by ThinkOfOneLet me clarify those comments.
Well, based on where you started:I dont think OCD is such a bad thing.
Religous fervor can be a good thing. I dont know, I try to see the positive side of things. There is usually a positive side.
Seems likely that you're kidding yourself and me here.
I believe there are different types of OCD.
A story that comes to mind is about a woman who chanted. She chanted so much that everyone around her thought she was mad.
But she would keep on chanting until one day-Bam!!, she was enlightened. From then on she never chanted again..
So her OCD may have been beneficial in the end, however I'm sure there are many more similar stories where the ending has not been so happy...
edit: so yes, I am kidding myself and you for the most part but then every now and then a crazy chanting lady comes along and....
(every now and then there is a positive side)
Originally posted by karoly aczelWell, even if the story is true, I suspect you might be assuming a cause and effect that may not be true. For example, let's substitute the "chanter" with a "serial killer".
Let me clarify those comments.
I believe there are different types of OCD.
A story that comes to mind is about a woman who chanted. She chanted so much that everyone around her thought she was mad.
But she would keep on chanting until one day-Bam!!, she was enlightened. From then on she never chanted again..
So her OCD may have been beneficial i ...[text shortened]... d then a crazy chanting lady comes along and....
(every now and then there is a positive side)
Originally posted by ThinkOfOneIts one of those stories I resonate with. I really dont care if its true.
Well, even if the story is true, I suspect you might be assuming a cause and effect that may not be true. For example, let's substitute the "chanter" with a "serial killer".
And she was a chanter, not a serial killer.
But I take your point...