03 Feb '11 21:25>9 edits
I'm not the first to have asked the question which will follow after the preamble... Reveal Hidden Content
I think of *me*, i.e. the being that perceives the world around him, likes/dislikes things, thinks, plans, etc... as a manifestation of (or the interaction between) the material configuration of my brain with respect to inputs detected by my physical senses and experiences, memories/goals, etc.. catalogued within my material brain. If I get drunk, *me* turns into a silly sod who does all sorts of stupid "funny"(?) capers and professes how much his friends mean to him (much to my embarassment when I sober up). Reveal Hidden Content
If I were to have a serious brain injury, then *me* would also change, as is evidenced by others who have experienced precisely that. Again this seems consistent only with a material notion of soul (I question whether I even need this word!)
To put it bluntly I see no need to invoke the notion of a supernatural entity residing within myself that gives rise to the character behind the flesh. Instead of asking what a soul is, which in my experiences yields the vaguest of answers; I wish to know, beyond standard scriptural responses that I have some sort of "eternal-soul" or I was forged in the image of "God", chapter X, verse Y of Holy book Z says blah blah etc... where theists think I'm being short-sighted; that is:
which part of *me* cannot be accounted for by natural interactions and processes?...why???
(and asked it before a while back but didn\'t phrase my question from the outset to get the answer I\'m looking for)
I think of *me*, i.e. the being that perceives the world around him, likes/dislikes things, thinks, plans, etc... as a manifestation of (or the interaction between) the material configuration of my brain with respect to inputs detected by my physical senses and experiences, memories/goals, etc.. catalogued within my material brain. If I get drunk, *me* turns into a silly sod who does all sorts of stupid "funny"(?) capers and professes how much his friends mean to him (much to my embarassment when I sober up). Reveal Hidden Content
and then later vomit...violently
When I'm sober however, I feel no such compulsion to act in this way (or at least with anywhere near the same magnitude). Now I know alcohol reduces ones inhibitions, but it is still my personality/my character/my drives being directly affected by something physical - this is consistent with a material view of one's soul (i.e. it isn't supernatural), and not so consistent with a supernatural soul.
If I were to have a serious brain injury, then *me* would also change, as is evidenced by others who have experienced precisely that. Again this seems consistent only with a material notion of soul (I question whether I even need this word!)
To put it bluntly I see no need to invoke the notion of a supernatural entity residing within myself that gives rise to the character behind the flesh. Instead of asking what a soul is, which in my experiences yields the vaguest of answers; I wish to know, beyond standard scriptural responses that I have some sort of "eternal-soul" or I was forged in the image of "God", chapter X, verse Y of Holy book Z says blah blah etc... where theists think I'm being short-sighted; that is:
which part of *me* cannot be accounted for by natural interactions and processes?...why???