23 Jun '08 10:26>
Finally, someone has taken up my challenge to discuss the soul. josephw has said he would like to discuss it.
I am only interested in soul/spirit concepts that enable the person using them to make a claim that they will continue to be concious at some point after death. For example if someone says "I will go to heaven".
For example josephw said
"But I know that when I die physically, my soul and spirit will live forever."
and
"Don't you want to live forever? I can't imagine you wouldn't!"
Now its possible that my lack of a decoder ring is making me misunderstand such statements but I would think that anyone who offers me eternal life, is implying a continuity for my conciousness after death.
It is my argument that any such claim is incompatible with what we know about conciousness.
I am only interested in soul/spirit concepts that enable the person using them to make a claim that they will continue to be concious at some point after death. For example if someone says "I will go to heaven".
For example josephw said
"But I know that when I die physically, my soul and spirit will live forever."
and
"Don't you want to live forever? I can't imagine you wouldn't!"
Now its possible that my lack of a decoder ring is making me misunderstand such statements but I would think that anyone who offers me eternal life, is implying a continuity for my conciousness after death.
It is my argument that any such claim is incompatible with what we know about conciousness.