@FMF
I'd probably demand that the torture go ahead. It don't think my emotional reaction and decision makes it morally right though.
This informs us that you realize of your own moral imperfection. You might judge wrongly. You might be overcome with feeling to the point that you would make a wrong moral choice.
As a Christian I have to consider God who is complete in knowledge and perfect in morality, even being the very ground of morality.
I have to consider God whose balance of emotion and intellect is impossible to be lopsided.
I have to consider that the Teacher of warnings of eternal punishment has a moral character which is beyond human questioning. No one can put a candle to Jesus.
When He teaches about eternal punishment, it demands of me serious attention.
And I don't think this particular well-thumbed scenario undermines the broad prohibition on torture as established by international and national laws.
The scenario brings out that in spite of our best laid out principles to regulate decent norms by civilized people, there will invariably be tough issues, very hard cases, very difficult situations which will "slip through the cracks". These are particularly thorny exceptional circumstances. Right?
As a Christian I have to take into account that for God there are no such situation, being infinite in understanding. You and I as finite humans have many situations which our created human wisdom cannot handle.
But God's creation testifies of His eternal power and unlimited knowledge.
I cannot quickly assume that because you and I would make an error, God would.
I don't think the fact that you me would answer your question in the same way legitimizes torture as punishment for example.
As a Christian I have to consider there is a difference between you and I and Jesus Christ. Our character is quite questionable morally. I am persuaded that the Teacher a last judgment of the world displays an approved character that is beyond criticism. He is in fact too good for this world. Yet He came.
I also have to consider to what degree He thought judgment by God was a serious thing AND what He could do to save us from eternal judgment.
And I would say WHATEVER the details of being condemned by God, Jesus took it more seriously then ANYONE. He has taken this need more seriously then ANYTHING as a problem He could solve for the world.
We may argue over the word pictures used to portray the horror of eternal punishment. But that Jesus took our need to be SAVED from being judged by God with absolute ultimate and all-consuming dedication, can hardly be disputed.
In His whole life and especially in the Garden of Gethsemane and at Calvary Jesus took our need to be redeemed from eternal judgment too seriously for many of us to underestimate the significance of this.