Originally posted by SwissGambit
"Mistake" is not the right word. Think more of "repackaging".
It was brilliant, actually. First, they make the Messianic prophecy come true - one of the downfalls of prophecy is that everyone knows what is supposed to happen, so you just find someone who fits the details closely enough and force the small stuff.
Then he gets killed unexpectedly. Al ...[text shortened]... opting of the Judaic narrative. So ingenious that we're still talking about it 2000 years later.
Unlikely.
There are things Jesus said throughout the gospels which can only point to not only His divinity, but to His role as part of the Godhead..
In fact, the high priest Caiaphas accused Him of blasphemy, saying, "He hath spoken blasphemy; what further need have we of witnesses? behold, now ye have heard his blasphemy." What the other elders failed to remember that it is not "blasphemy" if it is true, if He IS the Son of God. Caiaphas just wanted the people assembled for Passover to not have a focus, someone calling himself the Christ, to rally around.
This was not a man "who fits the details closely enough". He IS the Son of God, the one who fulfilled prophecy. And He did not "get killed unexpectedly". He prophesied His own death and His resurrection, many times. He knew what He was getting into. In addition, Jesus appeared to them and hung around for the 40 days between His resurrection and His ascension. Many others saw Him during this time. They didn't have to "change the story".
However, I give you props for imagination. "Cool story, bro," as they say.