-Removed-A compass is supposed to point in a single direction, if all compasses pointed every
way without consistency they would not be useful, you may as well use the second
hand on a watch for directions.
Jeremiah 17:9
The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it?
-Removed-One's unique moral compass is a core part of one's personhood and character. If a moral compass is influenced by an internalized rigid ideology [if that forms part of the "nurture" component], then so be it.
This is how character, individuality and personality are formed.
As long as moral compasses are governing action and interaction, I think it's OK. I am resistant to the notion of thought crimes or moral compasses being used to preempt people "potentially being able to commit similar atrocities" because of the ideologies they have internalized.
@kellyjay saidA magnetic compass points to magnetic north. You are torturing the analogy. A compass is also a navigation aid. Morals are not affected by magnetic waves.
A compass is supposed to point in a single direction, if all compasses pointed every
way without consistency they would not be useful, you may as well use the second
hand on a watch for directions.
If you know somebody whose moral compass is ~ blimey ~ like "the second hand on a watch" - I don't think I have [you mean a sociopath or psychopath?] - ask them to come here to this thread to defend the way they navigate their way through a moral landscape.
Otherwise, enough with your ludicrous strawman.
@fmf saidWhat would you say a moral compass is supposed to do, point to our desires or
A magnetic compass points to magnetic north. You are torturing the analogy. A compass is also a navigation aid. Morals are not affected by magnetic waves.
If you know somebody whose moral compass is ~ blimey ~ like "the second hand on a watch" - I don't think I have [you mean a sociopath or psychopath?] - ask them to come here to this thread to defend the way they navigate their way through a moral landscape.
Otherwise, enough with your ludicrous strawman.
point to something moral? If all compasses point in every direction is that because
there is no such thing as moral right and wrongs, or our compasses are broken?
@kellyjay saidOur moral codes come from our parents, families, neighbours, workplaces, places of worship, schools and colleges, from our culture, from history and literature, and from the system of laws under which we live.
What would you say a moral compass is supposed to do, point to our desires orpoint to something moral?
Our moral compasses synthesize all this and then interact with our personal unique narratives in order to make moral evaluations and decisions about our actions.
If someone's conscience "points to their desires" and they harm, deceive or coerce others, then those around them can use their moral compasses to evaluate that person's actions and decide what to do.
@kellyjay saidI believe there are "moral right and wrongs", yes. The only way I can perceive such things is by using my moral compass. Isn't that how you do it too?
If all compasses point in every direction is that because
there is no such thing as moral right and wrongs, or our compasses are broken?
@kellyjay saidJeremiah does not speak for me. I think he is very misanthropic. I am more positive and optimistic about my fellow human beings. "Desperately sick", eh? The Abrahamic religions seem overly misanthropic to me.
Jeremiah 17:9
The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it?
@the-gravedigger saidGreat insight from a couch potato. Get up move around, lose some weight get the blood moving it might help.
Good people would do good things and bad people would do bad things. It takes religion to make good people do bad things.